The California Trial Penalty

In one county, Amador County, the average sentence duration was the same for felony guilty pleas as for trials. In the six other counties, the average sentence duration ranged from 2 times to 3.3 times longer in felony cases in which individuals chose to go to trial, compared to the sentence duration for individuals who entered guilty pleas.

For misdemeanor cases, the average sentence duration for trials ranged from 0.8 times the duration for guilty or nolo contendere pleas to 22 times longer for trial cases versus guilty plea or nolo contendere cases. For misdemeanors, there were 68 penal codes that exhibited a trial penalty, representing a total of 49,800 guilty plea cases and 775 trial cases. 62

Ratio of Avg Sentence Duration: Trial vs. Guilty/Nolo Deal

Felony

Misdemeanor

# County # of Penal Codes

Range

Average

Range

Average

1

Amador

7

0.5 ~ 1.3

1

0.8 ~ 7.6

3.5

2 Calaveras

4

0.9 ~ 3.1

2.3

16.9 ~ 16.9

16.9

3 El Dorado

37

0.3 ~ 34.3

3.3

0.1 ~ 10

3.2

4

Lassen

30

(No charge type data to support this comparison)

5

Modoc

21

0.7 ~ 14.2

3.3

0.1 ~ 83.3

9.3

6 Monterey

131

(No charge type data to support this comparison)

7 San Benito

19

0.2 ~ 8.1

2.5

0.1 ~ 1.6

0.8

8

Siskiyou

26

1.2 ~ 4

2.2

0.2 ~ 71

22

9

Ventura

208

0 ~ 16.7

2

0 ~ 27.4

2.5

4. Sentencing Comparison Snapshots by Discrete California Penal Code Subsections The datasets the Task Force analyzed provide a rich array of possibilities for examining the existence of a trial penalty using specific penal code subsections. The dataset for the combined seven counties (Amador, Calaveras, El Dorado, Modoc, San Benito, Siskiyou, and Ventura) contained a total of 1,062 distinct California Penal Code subsections. Of those, there were 150 code subsections for which there was at least one felony trial case and at least one felony plea case. Of those 150 felony penal code subsections, 100 of them exhibited a trial penalty (a sentencing ratio greater than 1, meaning the average trial sentence exceeded the average plea sentence). Five subsections reflected no disparity between the sentence length for felony cases that went to trial versus the sentencing length for cases that resulted in a guilty plea (a sentencing ratio of 1). In the remaining 45 felony penal code subsections, a trial benefit was reflected in the data (a sentencing ratio of less than 1). Similarly, the dataset contained 111 misdemeanor penal code subsections for which there was at least one trial and at least one guilty plea. Of those 111 code subsections, 68 penal codes exhibited a trial penalty (sentencing ratio greater than 1). Four penal code subsections reflected no disparity

between the sentence length for cases that went to trial compared to the sentencing length for guilty plea cases (a sentencing ratio of 1). In the remaining 39 penal code subsections, there was a trial sentencing benefit, meaning the average sentence length in the trial cases was less than the average sentence length in cases in which individuals entered guilty pleas (a sentencing ratio of less than 1).

a) Analysis of Penal Code

Subsections by Felony Trials The Task Force sorted the data to determine which felony offenses had the highest number of cases that went to trial in order to take a snapshot of the trial versus plea sentencing differential in these common cases. The penal code subsections with the most trials were: Lewd Act Upon a Child (§ 288(A)); Attempted Murder (§ 187(A)); 2nd Degree Robbery (§ 211); Burglary (§ 459); and Domestic Violence — Injury (§ 273.5(A)). We then analyzed the sentencing differential for these five offenses and learned that defendants experienced a trial penalty for 4 out of the 5. The trial penalty associated with those four penal code subsections ranged from 1.5 to 3.6 times the average sentences in trial cases compared to guilty plea cases. For one of the offenses, 2nd Degree Robbery, the average sentence for guilty pleas was longer than the average sentences in the trial cases. This data is displayed in greater detail in the table below:

40

THE CALIFORNIA TRIAL PENALTY: The Constitutional Right to Trial Under Attack 

Made with FlippingBook Online document maker