The California Trial Penalty

Avg. Sentence Trial Cases (days)

Avg. Sentence Guilty/Nolo Cases (days)

# of Trial Cases

# of Guilty/ Nolo Cases

Penal Code Penal Code Description

Ratio

288(A)

Lewd Act Upon Child

112

5480

197

1541

3.6

664/187

Attempted Murder

37

14,089

30

9220

1.5

211

2 nd Degree Robbery

37

2089

414

3163

0.7

459

Burglary

32

1167

1525

605

1.9

273.5(A)

Domestic Violence — Injury

30

1343

688

644

2.1

b) Analysis of Penal Code Subsections by Number of Misdemeanor Trials The Task Force then conducted the same analysis in misdemeanor cases by identifying the misdemeanor offenses that had the most cases go to trial. These were: DUI (§ 23152(a)); Driving with a .08 blood alcohol content (§ 23152(b)); Petty Theft (§ 484(a)); Resisting/Obstructing (§ 148(a)(1)); and DUI Drugs & Alcohol (§ 23152(f)). Again, of the five misdemeanor offenses with the most trials, four of them showed a trial penalty. For one of the five offenses, the average sentences were longer for the guilty pleas when compared to the trials, reflecting a trial benefit.

Avg. Sentence Trial Cases (days)

Avg. Sentence Guilty/Nolo Cases (days)

# of Guilty/ Nolo Cases

Penal Code Penal Code Description # of Trial Cases

Ratio

23152(a)

DUI

153

49

4394

20

2.4

23152(b)

Driving with .08 BAC

125

40

12,811

21

1.9

484(a)

Petty Theft

53

380

2834

43

8.9

148(a)(1)

Resisting/Obstructing

47

144

3438

59

2.4

23152(f)

DUI drugs & alcohol

37

26

1143

33

0.8

A young man with no prior offenses was charged in Santa Clara County with performing lewd acts with a minor and faced a potential life sentence. The prosecutor made an initial offer of 8 years, but the defendant rejected it, vigorously denying the allegations. After the preliminary hearing, but before trial, the defendant attempted to get the 8-year offer back. No new evidence had been found at the preliminary hearing. But the prosecutor said he would only settle at 18-20 years.

During a conference with the judge, defense counsel argued that 8 years would be reasonable, the judge suggested 10 and the probation officer suggested splitting the difference at 14. The prosecutor eventually reduced the offer to 12 years. The judge commented that 12 years was more reasonable than 18-20. Finding himself otherwise facing a life sentence if he went to trial, the defendant accepted 12 years, 50% higher than the original offer.

c) Analysis of Penal Code Subsections by Largest Trial Penalty — Felonies The five felony penal code subsections that resulted in the greatest sentencing disparity each produced sentences more than six times longer for felony trial cases when compared to felony guilty plea cases. The chart below shows the most severe trial penalty in the datasets in felony cases:

41

THE CALIFORNIA TRIAL PENALTY: The Constitutional Right to Trial Under Attack 

Made with FlippingBook Online document maker