The California Trial Penalty

Avg. Sentence Guilty/Nolo Cases (days)

# of Trial Cases

Avg. Sentence Trial Cases (days)

# of Guilty/ Nolo Cases

Penal Code Penal Code Description

Ratio

Maintaining Place for Drug Distribution

11366

5

2091

12

269

7.8

311.4(c)

Using Minor for Sex Acts

1

9125

13

1175

7.8

Dissuading Witness from Testifying Possession of Assault Weapon

137.1(b)(1)

3

3528

33

471

7.5

30605(a)

1

2190

51

317

6.9

22810(g)(1)

Use of Tear Gas

1

1460

15

237

6.2

d) Analysis of Penal Codes Subsections by Largest Trial Penalty — Misdemeanors The five misdemeanor penal code subsections that resulted in the greatest sentencing disparity each produced sentences more than 13 times longer for misdemeanor trials cases when compared to misdemeanor guilty plea cases. The Task Force notes that the data may be somewhat skewed by the relatively low number of tried cases. However, these cases indicate the extreme risk that defendants face if they exercise their constitutional right to trial. The chart below shows the most severe trial penalty in the datasets in misdemeanor cases:

Avg. Sentence Trial Cases (days)

Avg. Sentence Guilty/Nolo Cases (days)

Penal Code Description

# of Trial Cases

# of Guilty/ Nolo Cases

Penal Code

Ratio

Arrest While on Probation

1203.2

4

250

1

3

83.3

Violation of a Posted Order

4326(a)

1

200

13

7

27.4

22210

Possession of Blackjack

2

638

183

41

15.5

Carrying Loaded Firearm in Vehicle

25850(a)

2

638

95

43

14.9

Possession Controlled Paraphernalia

H&S 11634(a)

19

456

2174

33

13.9

Stephen Maffy The defendant who was charged with oral copulation and digital penetration of an intoxicated, unconscious person received a plea offer to a sexual battery charge and a non-sexual felony. The plea offer contemplated 3 years felony probation and a 10-year registration requirement

(i.e., no jail time). Defense counsel made one counter-offer to simple battery, which the prosecutor immediately rejected. The defendant went to trial. The jury deliberated for seven days. After three holdout jurors finally changed their votes to guilty, the defendant was convicted.

He received the maximum sentences on the charges, which ran consecutively. After rejecting a sentence involving no jail time before trial, the defendant received 12 years in prison and is subject to lifetime registration requirement.

42

THE CALIFORNIA TRIAL PENALTY: The Constitutional Right to Trial Under Attack 

Made with FlippingBook Online document maker