The California Trial Penalty

e) Life Sentence Probability Comparison 63 Two of the datasets contained information that allowed the Task Force to calculate the likelihood of an individual receiving a life sentence if they chose to enter a guilty plea compared to their likelihood of receiving a life sentence for the same penal code subsection if they went to trial. In El Dorado County, there were nine cases in which defendants were charged with murder pursuant to California Penal Code § 187(a). Four of the individuals entered guilty pleas and none of those four defendants received a life sentence. In contrast, five defendants in El Dorado County were convicted at trial of murder under § 187(a) and two of the defendants, 40% of those convicted at trial, received life without parole sentences.

In Siskiyou County, there were 11 penal codes that resulted in life sentences in cases associated both with guilty pleas on the one hand and convictions at trial on the other hand. In five of 124 cases (or four percent) in which individuals facing life sentences entered guilty pleas, the defendants received life sentences. In contrast, eight of the nine Siskiyou County defendants facing life sentences who went to trial received life sentences, constituting 89% of those defendants. In the Siskiyou County data, 14 defendants were charged with murder pursuant to § 187(a). Ten of those defendants pled guilty but only three received life sentences. In contrast, three out of the four defendants charged with murder pursuant to § 187(a) who were convicted at trial received a life sentence. 64

% of Cases Defendant Sent Life Sentence

Charge Type

# of Penal Codes

Guilty/ Nolo Plea

County

Trial

Admitted

Note

El Dorado

(1) Felony

1

0 of 4 (0%)

2 of 5 (40%)

N/A

In the Siskiyou data, there are 11 penal codes associated with a life sentence. Our analysis shows that defendants who pled guilty or nolo contendere have a smaller chance of receiving a life sentence.

5 of 124 (4%)

Siskiyou (1) Felony

11

8 of 9 (89%)

1 of 3 (33%)

Capital Murder Defendant A 19-year old man was charged in Alameda County with abduction, robbery and murder along with two accomplices after a robbery resulted in the killing of another man. Although the defendant was originally charged with capital murder, the prosecutor removed the death penalty request after the preliminary hearing, but still charged a special circumstance that meant the defendant would not have an opportunity for parole. The prosecutor offered a plea deal of 50 years to life. Under 26 years old at the time, the defendant qualified as a youthful offender under California’s

Youthful Offender Law, which meant that he would be eligible for parole after 25 years under the terms of the plea offer. However, facing at least 25 years in prison (when he was not yet 25 years old himself), the defendant rejected the plea offer and exercised his right to trial. The defendant was convicted and sentenced as a matter of law to life in prison without the possibility of parole. At sentencing, the prosecutor emphasized that the defendant had rejected a plea deal. The sentencing judge acknowledged that he had sympathy for the man’s situation and believed the man to be remorseful.

The judge said during the sentencing hearing that, “I know my hands are tied. Once the law says I got to do something, I’m going to do it. … And I just wish I didn’t have to do this to this young man at this time, but that’s what I have to do. … And I just – I’m just, as I say, it pains me, but this is what I have to do. And you know, I wish there was another way, but the law doesn’t allow me to do it another way. I have to do what’s right under the law right now because, now, this is the only choice I get. Before, I had choices. I don’t have that any further.” The first co-defendant agreed to six years and eight months in prison and the second co-defendant was never found.

43

THE CALIFORNIA TRIAL PENALTY: The Constitutional Right to Trial Under Attack 

Made with FlippingBook Online document maker