The California Trial Penalty

2015 SAN FRANCISCO OFFICE OF THE PUBLIC DEFENDER PLEA OFFER AND TRIAL DATA ANALYSIS

In 2015, the San Francisco Public Defender’s Office (“SF OPD”) tracked the plea offers, verdicts, and sentences for its clients who announced to the court and prosecutors that they wanted to go to trial. Specifically, the SF OPD kept data in 2015 for 222 felony and misdemeanor clients who rejected the State’s plea offers and chose to go to trial.

FELONY TRIAL DATA ANALYSIS The following chart shows the outcome of 64 felony cases 65 for SF OPD that went to trial in 2015.

Dismissal

Hung Jury

Mistrial

Not Guilty 66

Mixed Verdict 67

Guilty

1 (1.5%)

6 (9.3%)

2 (3.1%)

11 (17.1%)

31 (48.4%)

13 (20.3%)

Eleven of the 64 felony cases in 2015 (nearly 17%) ended with not guilty verdicts on the sole count or with not guilty verdicts on all counts for the SF OPD clients. An additional nine cases—over 13%—ended with a hung jury, some other form of mistrial, or the dismissal of the charges. This means that nearly one-third of all felony cases in which SF OPD clients elected to go to trial in 2015 resulted in a hung jury, mistrial, or a not guilty verdict on the sole or all counts (including one dismissal after the defendant announced ready for trial). Forty-four felony cases handled by SF OPD lawyers in 2015— over 68% of the 64 trial cases—resulted in guilty verdicts on at least one count. Thirty-one of those 64 cases—over 48% of the total cases or the equivalent of 70% of the guilty verdict cases—involved a mixed verdict (guilty on one or more counts and not guilty on others, including some cases with guilty verdicts only for misdemeanor offenses). Only 13 cases—just over 20% of the 64 total cases and about one-quarter of the guilty verdict cases—ended with a guilty verdict on the sole charge or on all counts. Turning to the sentences imposed by judges in the 44 cases that ended with guilty verdicts on at least one count, eight cases resulted in a trial penalty. For purposes of this analysis, a trial penalty means that the defendants were convicted of at least one felony offense and were sentenced

to longer terms of actual incarceration than the maximum sentences the defendants faced if they accepted the plea offer. Those eight cases are further described below. Before analyzing the trial penalty in those eight cases, it is helpful to explain why no trial penalty conclusion can be reached in the remaining 36 cases using this methodology. In some of the 36 cases, prosecutors did not make any plea offers. In other instances, prosecutors simply offered guilty pleas to specific counts or charges but did not offer any limitations on the length of the sentences or merely indicated that the State would request sentences to an undetermined number of years in state prison. In a handful of additional cases, the SF OPD did not record the sentences imposed by the courts after their clients were convicted at trial. Therefore, in the cases described in this paragraph, 19 felony cases in all, it is not possible to determine whether the SF OPD clients suffered a penalty by choosing to go to trial. Moreover, in 11 of the 36 cases, the SF OPD clients were charged with felonies but found guilty only of misdemeanors. Finally, in six of the cases, the post- trial sentence was less than the plea offer. Therefore, rather than suffering a trial penalty, 17 SF OPD clients (just over a quarter of those who went to trial and nearly 40% of all defendants in the SF OPD dataset

44

THE CALIFORNIA TRIAL PENALTY: The Constitutional Right to Trial Under Attack 

Made with FlippingBook Online document maker