The California Trial Penalty

TABLE OF CONTENTS

ABOUT THE NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF CRIMINAL DEFENSE LAWYERS AND THE NACDL FOUNDATION FOR CRIMINAL JUSTICE 

6

ABOUT THE CALIFORNIA ATTORNEYS FOR CRIMINAL JUSTICE 

6

FOREWORD 

7

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS 

8

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 

9

INTRODUCTION 

10

The Disappearance of Jury Trials in California Since 1980 

10

The Impact of the Disappearance of Jury Trials 

11

THE TRIAL PENALTY: RESEARCH AND BACKGROUND 

12

CALIFORNIA’S DISAPPEARING TRIAL 

15

SUMMARY OF IMPORTANT CALIFORNIA SENTENCING PROVISIONS 

16

DEFINING THE TRIAL PENALTY: PRACTITIONER EXPERIENCES AND SURVEY RESULTS 

17

Survey and Interview Methodology 

17

Defense Counsel Perspective: Trial Penalty And Coercion 

18

Existence and Occurrence of the Trial Penalty 

18

Coercion 

19

Defense Counsel Perspective: Case Characteristics and Defendant Demographics 

21

Defense Counsel Perspective: Manifestation of the Trial Penalty & Policy Impacts 

23

Procedural Issues 

25

Prosecutors’ Perspective: Prosecutor Survey Results 

27

Resolution of Cases by Plea 

27

Policies and Practices for Plea Offers 

28

The Trial Penalty 

31

ANALYSIS OF DATA COLLECTED FROM CALIFORNIA COURTS AND DISTRICT ATTORNEYS 

33

Data Collection Efforts And Data Analysis Methodology 

34

Public records data requests and responses 

34

Usable data sets 

35

Prevalence of Guilty Pleas Versus Trials 

37

Penal Code Analysis 

38

Probability of Misdemeanor Versus Felony Conviction 

38

Methodology for Identifying a Trial Penalty Using Sentencing Comparisons by Penal Code 

39

Statistical Analyses of Sentencing Duration Across Seven Counties 

39

Made with FlippingBook Online document maker