TABLE OF CONTENTS
ABOUT THE NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF CRIMINAL DEFENSE LAWYERS AND THE NACDL FOUNDATION FOR CRIMINAL JUSTICE
6
ABOUT THE CALIFORNIA ATTORNEYS FOR CRIMINAL JUSTICE
6
FOREWORD
7
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
8
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
9
INTRODUCTION
10
The Disappearance of Jury Trials in California Since 1980
10
The Impact of the Disappearance of Jury Trials
11
THE TRIAL PENALTY: RESEARCH AND BACKGROUND
12
CALIFORNIA’S DISAPPEARING TRIAL
15
SUMMARY OF IMPORTANT CALIFORNIA SENTENCING PROVISIONS
16
DEFINING THE TRIAL PENALTY: PRACTITIONER EXPERIENCES AND SURVEY RESULTS
17
Survey and Interview Methodology
17
Defense Counsel Perspective: Trial Penalty And Coercion
18
Existence and Occurrence of the Trial Penalty
18
Coercion
19
Defense Counsel Perspective: Case Characteristics and Defendant Demographics
21
Defense Counsel Perspective: Manifestation of the Trial Penalty & Policy Impacts
23
Procedural Issues
25
Prosecutors’ Perspective: Prosecutor Survey Results
27
Resolution of Cases by Plea
27
Policies and Practices for Plea Offers
28
The Trial Penalty
31
ANALYSIS OF DATA COLLECTED FROM CALIFORNIA COURTS AND DISTRICT ATTORNEYS
33
Data Collection Efforts And Data Analysis Methodology
34
Public records data requests and responses
34
Usable data sets
35
Prevalence of Guilty Pleas Versus Trials
37
Penal Code Analysis
38
Probability of Misdemeanor Versus Felony Conviction
38
Methodology for Identifying a Trial Penalty Using Sentencing Comparisons by Penal Code
39
Statistical Analyses of Sentencing Duration Across Seven Counties
39
Made with FlippingBook Online document maker