The California Trial Penalty

Sentencing Comparison Snapshots by Discrete California Penal Code Subsections 

40

Analysis of Penal Code Subsections by Felony Trials 

40

Analysis of Penal Code Subsections by Number of Misdemeanor Trials 

41

Analysis of Penal Code Subsections by Largest Trial Penalty — Felonies 

41

Analysis of Penal Codes Subsections by Largest Trial Penalty — Misdemeanors 

42

Life Sentence Probability Comparison 

43

2015 SAN FRANCISCO OFFICE OF THE PUBLIC DEFENDER PLEA OFFER AND TRIAL DATA ANALYSIS 

44

Felony Trial Data Analysis 

44

Felony Trial Penalty Cases 

46

Misdemeanor Trial Data Analysis 

48

Misdemeanor DUI Trial Penalty Cases 

49

Miscellaneous Misdemeanor Trial Penalty Cases 

50

CONCLUSION 

51

PRINCIPLES AND FINDINGS 

53

POLICY RECOMMENDATIONS 

54

Restore Respect for the Right to Trial 

54

Don’t Allow Sentencing to Be Based on the Decision to Exercise the Right to Trial 

54

Restore Respect for the Presumption of Innocence 

54

Prohibit the Use, and Impact, of Pretrial Detention, or Conditions of Release, on an Individual’s Right to Trial  54

Restore Judicial Independence and Judicial Discretion to Fit the Punishment to the Crime 

54

Eliminate or Reform Mandatory Sentencing Schemes 

54

Protect Judicial Independence and Require Proportionate Sentencing Directives 

55

Eliminate Barriers to Post-Conviction Innocence Claims for Individuals Who Pled Guilty as a Result of Coercive Plea Bargaining 

55

Authorize Judicial “Second Looks” and Expand the Availability of Clemency and Compassionate Release  55

Restore Effective Assistance of Counsel Before Plea Bargaining 

55

Guarantee Informed and Voluntary Pleas by Ensuring Effective Assistance of Counsel Before Plea Bargaining  55

Restore Transparency and Accountability 

55

Require Courts to Impose the Least Restrictive Appropriate Disposition 

55

Require Transparency in Charging, Plea Bargaining, and Sentencing 

55

Establish a Criminal Justice Data and Accountability Dashboard 

55

ENDNOTES 

56

APPENDIX 1: DEFENSE COUNSEL SURVEY 

61

APPENDIX 2: PROSECUTOR SURVEY 

84

APPENDIX 3: EXAMPLES OF OUTREACH LETTERS 

105

Made with FlippingBook Online document maker