The California Trial Penalty

instead was convicted of first-degree murder and sentenced to life with the possibility of parole after serving at least 25 years in prison. Another defendant was offered a guilty plea to oral copulation with a minor with a maximum penalty of 12 years in prison and was convicted of all charges at trial and was sentenced to 25 years to life.

MISDEMEANOR TRIAL DATA ANALYSIS The following chart shows the outcome of 158 misdemeanor cases tracked by the SF OPD in 2015 for their clients who rejected plea offers and indicated they wanted to go to trial.

Trial Penalty % Total Cases

Trial Penalty % Guilty Verdicts

Mixed Verdict

Dismissal

Hung Jury

Mistrial

Not Guilty

Guilty

15/158 (9.4%)

15/103 (14.5%)

5 (3.1%)

14 (8.8%)

10 (6.3%)

26 (16.4%)

55 (34.8%)

48 (30.3%)

Twenty-six of the SF OPD’s 158 misdemeanor cases (16.4%) resulted in not guilty verdicts on the sole count or not guilty verdicts on all counts for their clients. Fourteen other cases (8.8%) ended with a hung jury, ten cases (6.3%) led to a mistrial, and five cases (3.1%) were dismissed by prosecutors after the defendants announced ready for trial. Overall, 55 of the total 2015 misdemeanor cases (34.8%) in which SF OPD clients rejected the plea offers and announced that they wanted to go to trial did not lead to any conviction. In contrast, just over 65% of the total misdemeanor cases brought by prosecutors against SF OPD clients who elected a jury trial ended in a guilty finding of some sort. Specifically, 48 of 158 cases (30.3%) ended

with guilty verdicts on all counts while an additional 55 cases (34.8%) resulted in a mixed verdict. An examination of the sentences imposed on SF OPD clients convicted of misdemeanor offenses in the 103 cases with a guilty verdict on at least one count reveals that a trial penalty 68 occurred in 15 cases when the SF OPD clients rejected the plea offers, representing 9.4% of the 158 total cases. As a proportion of the cases that ended with a guilty verdict on at least one count, the 15 trial penalty cases constituted 14.5% of the 103 cases in that category.

48

THE CALIFORNIA TRIAL PENALTY: The Constitutional Right to Trial Under Attack 

Made with FlippingBook Online document maker