The California Trial Penalty

MISDEMEANOR DUI TRIAL PENALTY CASES The most common substantive crime among the 15 trial penalty cases involved DUI offenses. Nine of the 15 trial penalty cases were Driving Under the Influence charges in some form. 69

One defendant in the SF OPD misdemeanor dataset was charged with DUI and received an offer to plead guilty to DUI with 15 days of SWAP. After being convicted of DUI at trial, the court sentenced the defendant to 25 days in the county jail with credit for eight days time served. In two other DUI cases, the SF OPD clients were offered a guilty plea involving 20 days at the county jail performing community service (a SWAP offer). After rejecting the plea offer and going to trial, their sentences included 10 days in the county jail and 35 days of SWAP, for the first defendant, and 90 days performing SWAP while at the county jail for the second defendant. Another client received a pretrial plea offer involving 30 days of SWAP, but after rejecting the plea and going to trial, they received a sentence including 60 days in the county jail with one day credit for time served. Finally, one of the misdemeanor DUI cases involved an SF OPD client who was offered a plea to a second DUI with a sentence of 20 days SWAP. But after trial and conviction for DUI, the court sentenced the defendant 30 days in the county jail with two days credit for time served. The following chart depicts the nine misdemeanor DUI trial cases that demonstrated a trial penalty in the SF OPD data from 2015:

In two of the DUI cases, prosecutors offered the defendants the opportunity to plead guilty to the lesser charge of reckless driving involving alcohol with no potential executed jail time, which is colloquially known as a “wet reckless” charge. After rejecting the plea offers, going to trial, and being convicted of DUI, these defendants received sentences that included 10 days in the county jail performing community service (known as “SWAP” 70 ) and 30 days in the county jail with credit for one day time served, respectively. In two cases, the SF OPD clients received standard first DUI offers (which ordinarily guarantee no jail time) but in the second of the two cases the offer also included 20 days of SWAP community service. However, after rejecting the plea offers, the defendants received sentences, after being convicted at trial, that included 15 days in the county jail with two days credit for time served and 45 days in the county jail with credit for six days time served respectively.

*Plea offer was a wet reckless charge **Plea offer was a standard DUI offer with no jail time

49

THE CALIFORNIA TRIAL PENALTY: The Constitutional Right to Trial Under Attack 

Made with FlippingBook Online document maker