MISCELLANEOUS MISDEMEANOR TRIAL PENALTY CASES The remaining six misdemeanor cases in which a trial penalty was imposed by courts at sentencing involved a range of other substantive offenses. In a theft case, 71 the defendant received a plea offer to theft with no jail but, after conviction at trial, the court imposed a sentence that included eight months in the county jail. In an assault case under a statute that specifically applies to victims who are in the transportation industry (bus, streetcar, taxi etc.), 72 after the defendant rejected a plea offer including 100 days in the county jail, they went to trial, were found guilty, and the court imposed a sentence that included 180 days in the county jail. Three misdemeanor trial penalty cases involved weapons charges. The prosecutor offered a guilty plea in a case involving the possession of brass knuckles 73 with a deferred
entry of judgment for a year (an offer contemplating no incarceration). When the defendant instead chose to go to trial, the court imposed a sentence of ten days in the county jail with credit for ten days time served. In two gun possession cases, 74 the pretrial offers were identical and included 90 days in the county jail. After the defendants rejected the plea offers and were convicted at trial, the courts sentenced them to 120 days and 160 days in the county jail respectively. Finally, in a sex offense case involving touching an intimate part of a person against their will, 75 the defendant rejected a plea offer to indecent exposure with a maximum sentence of one year in the county jail, was convicted of all of the charges, and received an eighteen- month sentence in the county jail by the trial court. The following chart depicts the remaining six miscellaneous misdemeanor trial cases that demonstrated a trial penalty in the SF OPD data from 2015:
*Plea offer included no jail time
50
THE CALIFORNIA TRIAL PENALTY: The Constitutional Right to Trial Under Attack
Made with FlippingBook Online document maker