CONCLUSION
The research, surveys, interviews, data collection, and analysis conducted by the Task Force confirm that a trial penalty exists in California criminal cases. Data shows that at the same time that the California crime rate has fallen over the past 45 years since 1980, the prison population has swelled. Concurrently, the number of criminal defendants entering guilty pleas to felony charges has skyrocketed and the proportion of felony cases resolved by guilty pleas has also risen. In contrast, the percentage of criminal defendants who have exercised their constitutional right to trial over the past 45 years has dropped from 12.4% in 1979/1980 to 2.2% in 2023/2024. The Task Force’s survey of over 700 California defense counsel, from 53 out of California’s 58 counties, shows that criminal defense lawyers firmly believe that a trial penalty exists in California. Their view was explained in follow-up interviews with nearly two dozen survey respondents. The consensus expressed in the survey and interviews was that the trial penalty exists due to a variety of factors, including: (1) structural sentencing features (including mandatory minimum sentences, other sentencing enhancements, and California’s Determinate Sentencing Law) that remove or limit judges’ discretion in sentencing or create presumptions for specific sentencing ranges that are widely followed by judges; (2) plea practices by line-level district attorneys, specifically offering reduced sentences in exchange for guilty pleas and seeking enhanced sentences for defendants choosing to go to trial; (3) in some locations, apparent plea offer policies by elected District Attorneys or their supervisory assistants to seek enhanced sentences after trial compared with sentences sought after guilty pleas; (4) in some cases, the involvement by judges in plea negotiations and/or comments made by judges before sentencing indicating their sentences will be more severe for defendants if convicted after trial; and (5) sentencing practices by judges imposing lengthier sentences on defendants who exercise their constitutional right to trial compared to those who forego trials and enter guilty pleas. Defense counsel observed the trial penalty regardless of case type (in misdemeanor and felony cases and for less serious substantive offenses and the most serious crimes) and across a range of demographic factors (gender, race, ethnicity, citizenship/immigration status, and age). Defense counsel respondents were more
definitive in their belief that a trial penalty existed in felony cases versus misdemeanors. And respondents had differing views on the role that their clients’ demographic factors played with majority of respondents reporting judges do not impose trial penalty based on race, gender, ethnicity, or other constitutional classification. Indeed, a slim majority said those factors did not impact whether a penalty occurred. Defense counsel broadly believed that the trial penalty had caused marked negative effects on their individual clients and on the criminal legal system in California. Those negative impacts included a confluence of factors creating a coercive environment that pressures their clients to forego constitutional rights to seek pretrial release, challenge evidence against them, exercise their right to trial, and/or appeal errors that occurred in their cases. The overwhelming majority of defense counsel survey and interview respondents stated that the trial penalty resulted in substantial increased penalties for the small portion of their clients who risked going to trial and who were convicted. The Task Force received a much more limited response to its survey of prosecutors. Only 25 prosecutors from eight California counties responded to the survey. The small sample of prosecutors who responded to the survey nearly unanimously stated that their offices did not have any Defendant and his girlfriend, both adults and frequent drug users, traveled around together in a shared vehicle that they both used to pick each other up from different locations. There was a history of domestic violence, and the girlfriend eventually alleged that the defendant was forcing her to stay in the vehicle against her will. The Santa Barbara County prosecutor charged the defendant with kidnapping, but the defendant maintained that he was innocent and that the girlfriend had always been free to leave. The prosecutor made an initial pre-trial offer, and then, just before jury selection, the prosecutor reduced the offer to 7 years. The defendant remained steadfast in his innocence and went to trial. After being found guilty of all charges except one, the defendant was sentenced to 29 years, more than 4 times the sentence the prosecutor had offered just before trial.
51
THE CALIFORNIA TRIAL PENALTY: The Constitutional Right to Trial Under Attack
Made with FlippingBook Online document maker