The California Trial Penalty

formal plea offer policies regarding conditions on plea offers or that required changes to sentencing positions for defendants who reject plea offers. However, most responding prosecutors reported that subsequent plea offers made after initial plea offers are rejected are less favorable and they acknowledged requiring waiver of a range of rights as a condition of defendants accepting plea offers. About 40% of prosecutors agreed that a trial penalty existed in their counties in misdemeanor and felony cases. But in contrast to defense counsel, prosecutors generally attributed the trial penalty to mandatory sentencing requirements, discounted plea offers after constitutional or factual infirmities in their cases arose, or sentencing practices of judges. The overwhelming majority of prosecutors responded that their practice was to argue for the same sentence after trial as was offered in the last plea offer to defendants. Despite the impressions of prosecutors as expressed in their responses to the Task Force’s survey, the data obtained from multiple sources by the Task Force and analyzed starkly confirmed the existence of the trial penalty in rural, urban, and suburban areas of California. The first tranche of data the Task Force obtained came from a subset of California Superior Courts and District Attorneys’ Offices, constituting hundreds of thousands of cases over about a ten-year period from 2013 to 2023. The courts or prosecutors in seven counties maintained data in a way that allowed the comparison of the actual sentences for defendants who pled guilty versus those who went to trial. Regardless of the severity of the charges—misdemeanor or felony; property, non-violent, or violent crime—a statistically significant trial penalty appeared in the data for the tens of thousands of

defendants whose records were analyzed. The vast majority of those defendants chose to plead guilty and they received measurably shorter sentences in aggregate than their counterparts charged under the same California penal code who elected to go to trial. The trial penalty also existed in the much smaller set of defendants from two counties where an analysis could be conducted between the defendants facing life sentences due to the nature of their crimes. The second tranche of data that the Task Force obtained came from the San Francisco Office of the Public Defender. In 2015, the SF OPD recorded the plea offers and sentences in misdemeanor and felony cases that went to trial that year. That data reflected significantly longer sentences for the defendants convicted after trial compared to the pretrial offers in both misdemeanor and felony cases. The trial penalty that has been captured in this report has had profound impacts on the criminal justice system in California over the past 45 years. During that period, the criminal legal system in California has been transformed from one in which the possibility that a defendant would get their day in court at a trial to test the evidence against them was real. Today, that possibility has all but vanished. Community members—whose voices in their role as jurors either affirmed or rejected the arrest and prosecution decisions of police and prosecutors— have nearly been silenced. The Task Force believes that the reforms proposed below can begin to shift the tide in ways that will simultaneously strengthen and make more accountable California’s criminal justice system.

52

THE CALIFORNIA TRIAL PENALTY: The Constitutional Right to Trial Under Attack 

Made with FlippingBook Online document maker