The California Trial Penalty

PRINCIPLES AND FINDINGS

1. The “trial penalty”—when defendants face drastically harsher sentences for exercising their constitutional right to trial—undermines the very foundation of justice by having all but extinguished the right to trial as guaranteed by the Sixth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution. 2. This report, along with NACDL’s groundbreaking reports analyzing the trial penalty in federal courts and in the New York State and Connecticut state courts, exposes the undeniable existence of a systemic injustice that coerces guilty pleas, deepens racial and economic disparities, and erodes public confidence in the criminal legal system. Therefore, addressing the trial penalty is essential to restoring fairness, transparency, and integrity to American justice. 3. This report establishes—through its surveys, anecdotes, and statistical analysis of a wealth of data—that the trial penalty is a pervasive and intimidating reality in California. Defendants face demonstrably longer, sometimes exponentially longer, sentences if they choose to exercise their constitutional right to challenge the accusations against them by going to trial. That risk has led to an overuse of and imbalance of power in the plea bargaining system, a marked drop in the number of jury trials, and a concentration of power in prosecutors. The consequences for the criminal justice system are significant, because the trial penalty prevents accountability by police and prosecutors through robust pretrial and trial

challenges of the evidence in the cases brought by the police and pursued by prosecutors, resulting in over-policing and prosecution of cases that might never stand up to scrutiny without the trial penalty. Thousands of cases of wrongful convictions of the innocent across the country, including as many as a quarter of cases where innocent defendants have pled guilty to crimes they did not commit because of the threat of more severe penalties if they went to trial, is another pernicious consequence of the trial penalty. While we do not seek to eliminate plea bargaining, we do seek to eliminate its increasingly coercive nature.

4. The trial penalty promotes increased police and prosecutorial misconduct by shielding it from public view and judicial scrutiny.

5. The trial penalty punishes persons for exercising their constitutional rights, effectively nullifying the right to the American justice system’s bedrock safeguards: the presumption of innocence, and

the right to be convicted only by sufficient, lawfully obtained evidence meeting the legal standard of proof beyond a reasonable doubt.

6. The elimination of criminal trials erodes the oversight function of the jury, thereby muting the voice of lay people in the criminal legal system.

7. The elimination of criminal trials undermines public faith in the legitimacy and fairness of the criminal legal system.

53

THE CALIFORNIA TRIAL PENALTY: The Constitutional Right to Trial Under Attack 

Made with FlippingBook Online document maker