The California Trial Penalty

POLICY RECOMMENDATIONS

RESTORE RESPECT FOR THE RIGHT TO TRIAL 1. Don’t Allow Sentencing to Be Based on the Decision to Exercise the Right to Trial Judges and prosecutors should be directed to respect the constitutional right to trial and, therefore, not consider the exercise of this right in recommending or imposing a criminal justice sentence except within specific, limited, and clearly articulated sentencing guidelines. Specifically, we recommend the following measures:

on liberty may not be imposed if they are intended to undermine an individual’s right to trial or if they have the effect of undermining the right to trial. This both ensures the right to trial and complies with the California Supreme Court’s holdings in Humphrey and Kowalczyk that attainable bail is constitutionally required. 76 RESTORE JUDICIAL INDEPENDENCE AND JUDICIAL DISCRETION TO FIT THE PUNISHMENT TO THE CRIME 3. Eliminate or Reform Mandatory Sentencing Schemes Repeal mandatory minimum sentencing and sentencing enhancements that eliminate judicial discretion, including firearm, gang, and repeat- offender provisions, and ensure meaningful sentencing discretion statewide. Specific reforms should include:

Enact legislation prohibiting prosecutors from seeking, and judges from imposing, harsher sentences based on an individual’s decision to exercise his or her right to trial or any other constitutional right.

}

} Amend the Code of Judicial Ethics to prohibit imposition of a greater sentence in retaliation based on an individual’s decision to exercise his or her right to trial or any other constitutional right. } Amend the Rules of Professional Conduct, Rule 3.8, to prohibit prosecutors from seeking a greater sentence or punishment based on an individual’s decision to exercise his or her right to trial or any other constitutional right. } Establish a rule that requires prosecutors to state, on the record, the bases for differences in sentencing recommendations made for individuals convicted

Watson Murder Reform : Establish a triad sentencing scheme (e.g., 10–20–life) for implied malice DUI murders to restore proportionality and judicial discretion. 77

}

} Repeal or Reform “Three Strikes” Sentencing or Limit its Scope : The Three Strikes Law should be repealed in order to allow judges to impose punishment based on all relevant criteria. At a minimum, legislation should remove juvenile adjudications for offenses committed before age 18 and implied intent crimes, such as Estes robberies, 78 should not count as serious or violent felonies. } Eliminate Mandatory Probation Bars : Repeal provisions, including Penal Code § 1203.066,

pursuant to a guilty plea and those convicted in the same case pursuant to a jury verdict.

RESTORE RESPECT FOR THE PRESUMPTION OF INNOCENCE 2. Prohibit the Use, and Impact, of Pretrial Detention, or Conditions of Release, on an Individual’s Right to Trial Judges must consider the effect of pretrial detention, or conditions of release, on an individual’s ability to exercise his or her right to trial. Pretrial restrictions

that categorically bar probation. Restore judicial authority to impose alternatives to incarceration where appropriate.

} Allow Judges to Consider and Remove Collateral Consequences : Authorize judicial discretion to waive sex offender registration and other severe collateral penalties where appropriate.

54

THE CALIFORNIA TRIAL PENALTY: The Constitutional Right to Trial Under Attack 

Made with FlippingBook Online document maker