4. Protect Judicial Independence and Require Proportionate Sentencing Directives Judicial performance evaluations and assignments in criminal cases should not be based on “efficiency” in resolving cases. Specifically, evaluations and assignments in criminal cases should not be conditioned on “efficiency” metrics (including trial rates, evidentiary rulings, or speed of disposition). 5. Eliminate Barriers to Post-Conviction Innocence Claims for Individuals Who Pled Guilty as a Result of Coercive Plea Bargaining 6. Authorize Judicial “Second Looks” and Expand the Availability of Clemency and Compassionate Release Authorize courts to review and modify lengthy post-trial sentences after substantial service of the sentence to ensure continuing proportionality and fairness. The ability to initiate second looks at sentencing should be broadened beyond the current scope of Cal. Penal Code § 1172.1, which allows only for DOC- or DA-recommended reviews, to expressly authorize defendants to seek sentence reductions after meeting established eligibility criteria. Eligibility for early release should be broadened to include rehabilitation, advanced age, serious illness, and extraordinary circumstances. Eligibility for sentencing second looks under Cal. Penal Code § 1170.91, currently available only to military veterans, should be expanded. Individuals who pled guilty should be permitted to seek clemency on grounds of actual innocence, and a rebuttable presumption in favor of release should be established when specified criteria are satisfied. RESTORE EFFECTIVE ASSISTANCE OF COUNSEL BEFORE PLEA BARGAINING 7. Guarantee Informed and Voluntary Pleas by Ensuring Effective Assistance of Counsel Before Plea Bargaining No plea should be accepted unless the defendant has received discovery sufficient to make a knowing and voluntary decision, and legislation should prohibit prosecutors from conditioning plea offers on the waiver of constitutional or statutory rights, including the right to seek pretrial release, obtain discovery or Brady disclosures, investigate, or litigate pretrial motions. Prosecutors and courts may not set arbitrary and coercive plea deadlines that effectively undermine the right to effective assistance before entering a plea.
agency, in any misdemeanor or felony case, to provide full discovery after the defendant’s first appearance, whether in person or through counsel. The prosecution must disclose all information and reports then in the possession of the prosecution team concerning the defendant or the charges within 72 hours of the first court appearance, excluding Sundays and holidays. After the initial disclosure, the prosecution must provide any new or additional reports or information concerning the defendant or the charges within 72 hours of receipt by the prosecuting agency or its investigating agencies. Disclosures must be made to defense counsel, or directly to the defendant if the court has granted pro per status.
RESTORE TRANSPARENCY AND ACCOUNTABILITY
8. Require Courts to Impose the Least Restrictive Appropriate Disposition Amend Rule 4.410 to require courts to impose the least restrictive sentence in light of all relevant facts and in light of statutory sentencing objectives and to explain, on the record, the bases for concluding that there is “no less restrictive means” to accomplish these objectives. 9. Require Transparency in Charging, Plea Bargaining, and Sentencing Prosecutors should document and justify charging decisions, plea offers, and sentencing recommendations. Courts, prosecutors, and defense agencies should be required to collect and publish standardized data on plea offers and trial outcomes — including the lowest plea offer extended, the sentence imposed after trial, and relevant case characteristics — to enable independent statewide evaluation of the trial penalty and sentencing disparities.
10. Establish a Criminal Justice Data and Accountability Dashboard
We recommend establishing an automated statewide criminal justice data dashboard collecting and publishing data from arrest through release. This infrastructure should provide the evidentiary foundation for ongoing reform by enabling independent evaluation of the trial penalty, sentencing disparities among co-defendants, racial and demographic disparities, disparities between guilty plea and trial convictions, and outcomes at every stage of the criminal process.
Specifically, we recommend amending the Penal Code to add a discovery provision requiring the prosecuting
55
THE CALIFORNIA TRIAL PENALTY: The Constitutional Right to Trial Under Attack
Made with FlippingBook Online document maker