The California Trial Penalty

ENDNOTES

1. In 1980, California residents experienced 886.9 violent crimes per 100,000 residents. In 2006, the California violent crime rate was 535.6 per 100,000 residents and in 2024 it was 490.8 per 100,000 residents. This reflects a decrease in the violent crime rate in that 44-year period of 44.7%. Property crime rates show an even more dramatic fall: in 1980 there were 6,880.6 property crimes per 100,000 residents, which then fell to 3,189.3 per 100,000 by 2006 and 1,969.6 in 2024. The property crime decrease over four and a half decades was over 71%. See https://www.cjcj.org/reports-publications/blog/ new-fbi-data-californias-crime-rate-is-at-record-lows- yet-crime-wave-lies-persist (“2024 FBI CJCJ Report”). 2. Despite the steady decline in crime rates, California’s prison population soared between 1980 and 2006, before dropping over the next 17 years. In 2006, the number of prison inmates in California had risen to 172,528, a more than seven-fold increase even while the violent crime rate had dropped by 40% and the property crime rate by 54% over that 26-year period.

5. “State court caseload statistics: Annual Report 1980” at 195. National Center for State Courts, available at https://bjs.ojp.gov/content/pub/pdf/ sccs80.pdf (“1980 State Courts Report”). The data presented in this section involves dispositions in 1979/1980 on cases filed as felonies, whether or not they resulted in guilty findings (via guilty pleas or trials) on felonies or misdemeanors or resulted in some other disposition other than guilty findings. 6. “ Court Statistics Report, Statewide Caseload Trends 1988- 89 through 1997-98 and Caseload Data for Individual Courts 1996-97 and 1997-98 ,” Judicial Council of California, Administrative Office of the Court, available at https://courts.ca.gov/sites/default/files/courts/ default/2024-12/1999csr.pdf (“1999 Annual Report”). 7. “ 2025 Court Statistics Report, Statewide Caseload Trends 2014-15 Through 2023-24 ,” Judicial Council of California, available at https://courts.ca.gov/system/files/file/2025- court-statistics-report.pdf (“2025 Court Statistics Report”). The data available for the 1997/1998 year is slightly different than the available data from 1979/1980 and 2023/2024. The available data for 1997/1998 reflects the total number of defendants convicted of felony crimes via guilty pleas or after trials, as well as the number of dispositions (acquittals or dismissals) of felony charges. Unlike the data from 1979/1980 and 2023/2024, the 1997/1998 data does not reflect the outcomes of all cases originally filed as felonies. See , Tables 13 through 18. Compare 1980 State Courts Report at 195 and 2025 Court Statistics Report: Statewide Caseload Trends, 2014-15 Through 2023-24 at Table 8a. 8. The significant increase in Other Dispositions in the 2023/2024 data, compared to the 1979/1980 and 1997/1998 data, may be explained by the establishment and growth in California of specialty courts such as drug courts and mental health courts.

By 2023, California’s prison population was still 94,188, nearly four times higher than in 1980. Id .

3. Racial bias in sentencing in California has been well documented. See, e.g . UC Law Journal, Dec. 2023, Proving Actionable Racial Disparity Under the California Racial Justice Act , Colleen V. Chien, W. David Ball, and William A. Sundstrom. This report, however, did not specifically analyze the relationship between the trial penalty in California, structural racism, and implicit bias. This relationship should be studied further using quantitative data because subjective surveys incorporate the biases of the respondents to the surveys. For this reason, as suggested in our recommendations, data should be collected to understand this relationship. 4. Crime-rate and incarceration-rate data were calculated by calendar year ( see “2024 FBI CJCJ Report”), while the trial-rate data in the following

Some use the equivalent term “trial tax.”

9.

chart are stated by fiscal year, reflecting the precise conventions of the underlying sources.

56

THE CALIFORNIA TRIAL PENALTY: The Constitutional Right to Trial Under Attack 

Made with FlippingBook Online document maker