66. In four of the 11 cases that resulted in a not guilty verdict, the jury hung on one or more counts. None of the defendants in those four cases were found guilty of any offenses.
72. Id. § 243.3.
73. Id. § 21810.
74. Id. § 25850(a).
67. In two of the 31 cases that ended with a mixed verdict, the juries could not reach a unanimous verdict on the felony counts but did find the defendants guilty on misdemeanor counts. In another mixed verdict case, the jury hung on all of the felony charges, but after the court declared a mistrial, the defendant accepted the prosecutor’s offer to plead guilty to a misdemeanor.
75. Id. § 243.4(e)(1).
76. See n.46, supra .
77. A “ Watson Murder” refers to a crime involving a death that occurs during a drinking and driving incident and, as a result, can be charged as a second degree homicide. The “triad” is a colloquial term referring to three distinct terms of incarceration, lower, mid, and upper, under California’s determinate sentencing scheme. Pursuant to a 2024 California Supreme Court case, California courts cannot go above the midterm of the triad unless facts supporting the enhancement are proven to the jury or admitted by the defendant. 78. People v. Estes , 147 Cal. App. 3d 23 (1983) (holding that use of force or threat of force while fleeing a shoplifting elevates the shoplifting to the more serious crime of robbery).
68. This analysis uses the same definition for a trial penalty as described above for the SF OPD felony trial penalty cases.
69. These cases involved charges under California Vehicle Code § 23152.
70. “SWAP” is a term for an out-of-custody community service program run by local detention centers. Defendants sentenced to SWAP must report to the county jail daily and then are assigned volunteer work to perform.
71. Cal. Penal Code § 487(c).
60
THE CALIFORNIA TRIAL PENALTY: The Constitutional Right to Trial Under Attack
Made with FlippingBook Online document maker