52. By comparison, nearly 30% of respondents to the defense counsel survey indicated that prosecutors coerce defendants into accepting a guilty pleas in felony cases by threatening increased sentencing in future offers. See page 21 above.
61. There were only five felony penal codes with an average sentence ratio of 1, meaning the defendants convicted pursuant to those penal codes on average received neither a trial penalty nor a trial benefit. The total number of guilty plea cases for those five penal codes was 458 and the total number of trials was ten, so this group represented a small fraction of the felony penal codes containing both plea dispositions and trial dispositions. Similarly, just under one-seventh of the felony cases analyzed produced an average sentence ratio of less than 1, representing a trial benefit. Those cases represented 45 distinct penal codes with a total of 2,080 plea cases and 146 trials. 62. There were only four misdemeanor penal codes with an average sentence ratio of 1, reflecting neither a trial penalty nor a trial benefit. Those penal codes involved just 175 plea cases and merely 7 trials. There were 45 penal codes that produced an average sentence ratio of less than 1, indicating the defendants sentenced pursuant to those penal codes received a trial benefit. There were just 2,645 plea cases and 107 trial cases among those 45 penal codes, or just over five percent of the misdemeanor cases analyzed for a trial penalty or trial benefit. 63. Although California has a death penalty statute permitting the imposition of a capital sentence under special circumstances, California has not executed a defendant who was sentenced to death since January 2006. In 2019, California Governor Gavin Newsom signed an executive order announcing a moratorium on executions which remains in effect as of the publication of this report. Hayley Bedard, Twenty Years Since Last Execution: California Remains Under Execution Moratorium as Advocates Push for Mass Clemency Grant , Death Penalty Information Center (2026), https://deathpenaltyinfo. org/twenty-years-since-last-execution-california-
53. Only nine of the 25 respondents provided responses here.
54. Only nine of the 25 respondents provided responses here.
55. California Penal Code § 1385 is a provision that authorizes California judges to dismiss a criminal action in the “furtherance of justice.” The authority can be on the court’s own motion or at the application of a prosecutor, pursuant to a number of specific factors, including mitigating factors such as the age, mental health history, non-violent nature of a felony, the inoperability of a weapon, or the significant potential sentence (over 20 years), as well as a factor that can be invoked if application of an enhancement provision would result in a discriminatory racial impact. 56. Examples of the records requests sent to district attorneys and the courts can be found in Appendix 3. 57. A “nolo contendere” plea, also referred to as a “no- contest” plea, involves a defendant who accepts a plea offer and allows the entry of a finding of guilt without admitting guilt to the charges. 58. Many, but not all, of the usable datasets the Task Force received distinguished between cases in which defendants entered guilty pleas and those in which defendants entered nolo contendere pleas. However, because both guilty plea cases and nolo contendere plea cases result in the entry of guilty verdicts against defendants without holding trials, in the analysis below, guilty pleas and nolo contendere pleas are collectively referred to as “guilty pleas.” 59. The Task Force received data for Siskiyou County from both the Superior Court and the District Attorney. The datasets from those two sources were not identical but duplicate data was removed before the analysis was conducted. 60. Penal code formatting may vary slightly between counties, even when referring to the same offense. For example, a DUI charge may appear as “23152(a) VC” in Ventura County’s data and as “VC23152(A)” in Siskiyou County’s data. These formatting differences result in technically different entries and were not normalized across counties. However, because this analysis was conducted within each county’s dataset, these variations do not affect the interpretation of the results.
remains-under-execution-moratorium-as- advocates-push-for-mass-clemency-grant.
64. The other Penal Code section in Siskiyou County that is associated with life sentences is § 269(a) which involves aggravated sexual assault of a child. 65. The SF OPD data included 65 cases, one of which involved a trial to determine whether or not the client was competent to stand trial. Because there was no plea offer in that case nor a trial with a traditional guilty/not guilty verdict and subsequent sentencing, it has been excluded from this trial penalty analysis.
59
THE CALIFORNIA TRIAL PENALTY: The Constitutional Right to Trial Under Attack
Made with FlippingBook Online document maker