41. Consistent with general county population levels, fewer responses were received from the state’s predominantly rural counties.
28. See also Ram Subramanian et al., In the Shadows: A Review of the Research on Plea Bargaining , at 44, Vera Inst. of Just. (Sept. 2020), https://vera-institute.files. svdcdn.com/production/downloads/publications/ in-the-shadows-plea-bargaining.pdf (“[R]esearch does appear to confirm that, among the millions of cases that are settled through guilty pleas each year, a meaningful number of people are actually innocent of the crimes with which they were charged.”). 29. See End the Trial Penalty, Sixth Amendment Right to Trial on the Verge of Extinction (last visited Sept. 9, 2026), https://www.endthetrialpenalty.org/.
42. The survey employed a pathing logic such that responses to certain questions dictated whether a respondent would be directed to subsequent explanatory questions. As an example, in instances where defense counsel responded affirmatively regarding the existence of a specific issue, they might then be directed to a subsequent question asking them to identify specific features or conditions of the issue. Respondents who did not identify the issue would be directed to the next sequence of questions. 43. Missing responses refers to instances where a respondent either left a specific question blank or instances where pathing logic, as described in note 42, directed a respondent past a certain question.
30. United States v. Walker , 423 F. Supp. 3d 281, 298 (S.D. W. Va. 2017).
31. New York v. Thomas , 34 N.Y.3d 545, 587 (2019) (Wilson, J., dissenting in part, concurring in part). 32. Comm. on Revision of the Penal Code, Annual Report and Recommendations 53 (2023) https://www. capolicylab.org/topics/criminal-justice/research- partner-california-committee-on-revision-of- the-penal-code/ (herein “2023 Annual Report”).
44. See id.
45. “Strikes for probation” generally refers to the practice of offering probation in exchange for a strike as part of a plea. If a defendant is subsequently convicted of a separate felony, the strike can result in a significant sentencing enhancement under California’s Three Strikes Law. 46. See In re Kowalczyk , 19 Cal.5th 593 (2026); In re Humphrey , 11 Cal.5th 135 (2021). 47. Under California Penal Code § 1538.5, a defendant may move for the return of property or to suppress evidence obtained as a result of an unreasonable search or seizure. 48. “TRC” is an abbreviation for a trial readiness conference, which occurs on the eve of trial. 49. In contrast to the defense counsel survey, which the Task Force sent to defense bar association and defense membership organizations (in addition to the leaders of California public defender and institutional defender organizations and offices), the Task Force did not have access to membership lists for prosecutor membership organizations. Instead, the Task Force relied on the 58 California District Attorneys to share the prosecutor’s survey with their colleagues and encourage them to respond.
33. Id.
34. Id.
35. Id . at 55 (quoting Professor Carissa Byrne Hessick, Testimony at the Committee on Revision of the Penal Code (Oct. 2, 2023) (Part 2 of 4, 0:07:15-0:07:27)). 36. Id. at 55 (citing Professor Amy Lerman, Testimony at the Committee on Revision of the Penal Code (Oct. 2, 2023) (Part 2 of 4, 0:13:32-0:14:20)).
37. See id. at 55-56.
38. The Judicial Council established rules of court for sentencing with a non-exclusive list of aggravating and mitigating circumstances, and standards for when they outweighed use of the middle term. 39. This refers to exculpatory material the government is required to provide to a defendant under Brady v. Maryland , 373 U.S. 83 (1963). 40. In many of these cases, clients understandably wished to keep identifying details of the incident confidential either for reasons of privacy or fear of retribution. Accordingly, where possible, stories are identified by the person’s name or by either a pseudonym or a name derived from some attribute of the case, where confidentiality was requested.
50. People v. Watson , 637 P.2d 279 (Cal. 1981).
51. California Penal Code § 1538.5 allows criminal defendants to request the suppression or exclusion of evidence in motions filed and, if not withdrawn, litigated before trial.
58
THE CALIFORNIA TRIAL PENALTY: The Constitutional Right to Trial Under Attack
Made with FlippingBook Online document maker