The California Trial Penalty

NACDL CACJ Trial Penalty Survey

FELONY CASES

3a. How frequently do prosecutors apply coercion to induce your client to accept a plea offer in your county? Examples of coercion might include, but is not limited to: threatening additional charges or threatening to withdraw a plea offer if the defense seeks pre-trial release or discovery or if the defense files motions including motions to suppress.

Rarely

Sometimes

Frequently



3b. How frequently do judges apply coercion to induce your client to accept a plea offer in your county? Examples of coercion might include, but is not limited to: threatening a higher or maximum sentence if the defendant does not accept the plea offer.

Rarely

Sometimes

Frequently



* 4a. At what stage of the proceedings do you most often resolve your cases by a guilty or no contest plea? (Check up to 3) At arraignment on the complaint After arraignment but before preliminary hearing After preliminary hearing, but prior to trial assignment or readiness conference Prior to receiving complete discovery

Prior to adjudication of motion to suppress evidence Prior to adjudication of PC 995 motion to dismiss Upon denial of motion for release from custody Other (please describe)

65

THE CALIFORNIA TRIAL PENALTY: The Constitutional Right to Trial Under Attack 

Made with FlippingBook Online document maker