NACDL CACJ Trial Penalty Survey
FELONY CASES
* 4b. Are prosecution offers conditioned on the defense foregoing discovery, refraining from bringing motions, or waiving appellate rights? (In other words, do clients have to give up litigation in order to take advantage of a favorable plea offer?)
{ Yes { No
* 4c. Which of the following are fairly common conditions on pleas in your county? (Check all that apply) Plea must be entered at first appearance after arraignment and bail setting Plea must be entered before litigating some defense motion - Sec. 1538.5, Pitchess, Discovery or enforcement of subpoenas duces tecum , etc. Plea must be entered before preliminary examination Plea requires foregoing a non-criminal disposition (i.e. diversion or similar) Plea must include admission of strikes or other sentence enhancements Plea must include waiver of appeal of denial of 1538.5 or other constitutional issues Plea must include waiver of appeal generally Plea must include admission to elements necessary for a future prosecution (i.e., “ Watson waivers”) requested or demanded by the prosecution Plea must include admission to elements necessary for a future prosecution (i.e., “ Watson waivers”) requested or demanded by the judge or court
4d. Do prosecutors often use direct or implied threats to encourage acceptance of offers? (For example “If you don’t take this before prelim it is off the table”, or “If you don’t take this, I’ll add charges”)
{ Yes { No
4e. Do judges or bench officers often use direct or implied threats to encourage acceptance of offers? (For example “If you don’t take this I’ll give your client the maximum”)
{ Yes { No
66
THE CALIFORNIA TRIAL PENALTY: The Constitutional Right to Trial Under Attack
Made with FlippingBook Online document maker