EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Jury trials have all but vanished in California and across the country. What we have instead isn’t the system of trials the Framers imagined. Our criminal legal system has become an assembly line of plea deals. And there’s a name for what’s driving it: the “trial penalty”— the gap, often a wide and punishing one, between the sentence someone gets after pleading guilty and the sentence they would get for exercising their right to a trial. Since 2018, NACDL has been tracking this penalty in the federal system and in state systems across the country. This report is about the trial penalty in California state cases. Let’s be clear about what’s at stake. The trial penalty doesn’t just punish people for using their right to trial— it chips away at it. And because guilty pleas almost always require the accused to give up claims that their constitutional rights were violated, it quietly undermines the Fourth, Fifth, and Sixth Amendments too. It also takes something away from all of us: the public’s ability to see how our courts and prosecutors are actually doing their jobs — something the Framers cared about deeply. In 2021, NACDL and CACJ created a Task Force of pro bono lawyers and data analysts to examine the trial penalty in California, its causes, and potential solutions. Over five years, the Task Force gathered and analyzed a decade of data from more than 1.5 million records statewide. Based on this data, the Task Force identified ten policy recommendations to limit and reverse the trial penalty’s damage to the individual and public rights the Constitution guarantees. The Task Force studied the problem using both subjective and objective data. First, the Task Force conducted a statewide survey of criminal defense lawyers and prosecutors which found that nine in ten California defense lawyers believe defendants are penalized for exercising their right to trial. The survey also found that some prosecutors held that view, but far less uniformly than did defense counsel.
The quantitative data told the same story. Drawing on sentencing outcomes from more than 1.5 million criminal cases in 14 of California’s 58 counties over ten years, the Task Force found that defendants are punished harshly for going to trial—in both felony and misdemeanor cases alike. In six counties with sufficient data for statistical comparison, felony defendants convicted at trial received sentences roughly three times longer than those who pled guilty, while in one rural county there was no disparity between the average sentences after guilty pleas and trials. In those counties, misdemeanor defendants convicted at trial fared even worse, with average sentences ranging between two-and-a-half times to a staggering 22 times longer than those for defendants who pled. Only one rural outlier county broke the pattern, with plea sentences running slightly longer than the sentences for defendants who went to trial. This differential represents a substantial trial penalty and explains why criminal trials have virtually vanished from California’s courts. In 1979-80, roughly 12.4% of felony cases in the Superior Courts in California went to trial. Less than 20 years later, by 1997-1998, the figure had fallen to just 4%. Since then, even that reduced number has been cut nearly in half. In 2023-24, just 2.2% of felony convictions in the California Superior Courts came from trial verdicts. Unsurprisingly, the data documenting the disappearance of misdemeanor trials are starker still—an astounding 99.2% of misdemeanor convictions are the result of pleas. Fewer than 1% of misdemeanor cases go to trial. Here’s what we want people to understand: none of this had to happen this way. The trial penalty isn’t some natural, unavoidable feature of our justice system. It’s the product of choices, made by people, at every level of state and local government. And choices can be unmade. That’s why the Task Force put together ten policy recommendations: to help restore the right to trial to the people of California.
9
THE CALIFORNIA TRIAL PENALTY: The Constitutional Right to Trial Under Attack
Made with FlippingBook Online document maker