INTRODUCTION
Since the 1980s, crime rates in California have dropped substantially 1 and our prison population has soared. 2 During the same 45-year period, jury trials have all but vanished from California, leaving in their place an assembly line of pleas rather than the system of trials envisioned by the Framers. Legal professionals and observers attribute the disappearance of trials to the “trial penalty”—the substantial and often extreme difference between the sentence received pursuant to a guilty plea and the sentence received after trial.
NACDL has studied the trial penalty across the country and, through this report, in California. NACDL has found that, across the country and in California, many factors contribute to the trial penalty, including mandatory sentencing, highly punitive sentencing, abuse of pre- trial detention, underfunding of public defense systems, and systemic racism. 3 This Report endeavors to identify the policy choices that drive the trial penalty in order to propose reforms that might restore the system of trials established in the Constitution to protect individual liberty and limit government power.
The Disappearance of Jury Trials in California Since 1980 While the reduction in trials has occurred in both misdemeanor and felony cases, the plunging felony trial rate over 45 years illustrates the evisceration of the right to trial. As reflected below, felony trial rates have plummeted approximately 83% since 1980, calling into question the integrity of an adversarial criminal legal system based on the constitutional premises that the criminally accused can challenge prosecutorial power and that the public can oversee this process as jurors serving in public trials. As the following charts demonstrate, felony trial rates dropped from 12.4% in fiscal year 1979/80 to 4.0% in 1997/98 to 2.2% in fiscal year 2023/24, representing a reduction of more than 67% over the first two decades and 83% over all four decades: 4
1979/1980 Other Dispositions of
1979/1980 Disposed Felony Cases 5 51,190
1979/1980 Guilty Pleas in Disposed Felony Cases 38,631 (75.5%)
1979/1980 Trials in Disposed Felony Cases 6,338 (12.4%)
Felony Cases 6,221 (12.1%)
1997/1998 Felony Dispositions 6 146,570
1997/1998 Felony Guilty Pleas 132,742 (90.5%)
1997/1998 Trials in Felony Cases 5,880 (4.0%)
1997/1998 Other Felony Dispositions 8,926 (6.0%)
2023/2024 Other Dispositions of
2023/2024 Disposed Felony Cases 7 123,063
2023/2024 Guilty Pleas in Disposed Felony Cases 89,440 (72.6%)
2023/2024 Trials in Disposed Felony Cases 2,682 (2.2%)
Felony Cases 30,941 (25.1%) 8
10
THE CALIFORNIA TRIAL PENALTY: The Constitutional Right to Trial Under Attack
Made with FlippingBook Online document maker