The California Trial Penalty

The Impact of the Disappearance of Jury Trials The extensive use of guilty pleas comes at a significant cost to criminal defendants, who are required in nearly all circumstances to waive their fundamental constitutional rights as a condition of pleading guilty—these include not only their right to a trial but also their Fourth, Fifth and Sixth Amendment rights to seek pretrial release; to obtain discovery, receive exculpatory evidence and meaningfully investigate; to challenge unlawfully obtained evidence; and even to appeal. The waiver of these fundamental constitutional rights, and the absence of transparency inherent in a public trial, not only harms defendants but also removes the public’s opportunity to check government overreach and abuse of individual rights—abuses that trials are designed to expose. The driving force behind an individual’s decision to accept a plea rather than pursue a trial is the trial penalty. 9 The trial penalty refers to the substantial difference between the sentences received by those convicted through guilty pleas and the greater sentences, on average, imposed on those convicted at trial. The potential for significantly longer and stricter sentences acts as a strong deterrent to an individual’s exercise of their constitutional rights, and such disparate outcomes suggest that the sentence prosecutors recommend after trial is a punishment for exercising those rights, rather than an accurate reflection of a defendant’s culpability. Simply put, criminal defendants are often coerced into pleading guilty rather than exercising their right to trial, given the outsized risk that conviction at trial poses.

This report of the California Attorneys for Criminal Justice Foundation (CACJ Foundation) and the National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers (NACDL) explores the trial penalty in California. In June 2021, the California Trial Penalty Project Task Force (the Task Force), a joint effort between the CACJ Foundation and NACDL, began a process to evaluate the extent and impact of the trial penalty in the California criminal legal system. This report explores those concerns on the basis of surveys of the criminal defense community and of prosecutors; Public Records Act requests and records requests pursuant to court rules; practitioner interviews; and analysis of data on case processing, convictions and guilty plea practices. The report begins with an overview of prior research and reporting on the scope and extent to which pleas are used in criminal proceedings in federal and state courts. It then examines the key drivers of the trial penalty in California, supported by survey responses and interviews from defense attorneys across the state and, to a significantly lesser extent, from prosecutors. In addition to the qualitative data, the report offers a quantitative analysis of the trial penalty through a review of conviction and sentencing data provided by the California courts, district attorney offices, and a public defender agency. Finally, the report provides policy recommendations to reduce the harm of the trial penalty and to allow individuals charged with criminal offenses in California to more freely exercise their constitutional rights.

11

THE CALIFORNIA TRIAL PENALTY: The Constitutional Right to Trial Under Attack 

Made with FlippingBook Online document maker