The California Trial Penalty

THE TRIAL PENALTY: RESEARCH AND BACKGROUND

The decrease in criminal trials in California is not an isolated occurrence. Over the past 45 years, criminal trials in the United States have withered from a fairly common phenomena in 1980 when about one in five federal convictions resulted from trials to only about three percent today. 10 Recent research shows the significant use of pleas to resolve criminal cases, with approximately 97% of federal criminal convictions resulting from pleas, 11 with certain jurisdictions resolving all of their criminal cases through pleas. 12 The extensive use of pleas to resolve criminal cases undermines the important role that jury trials play in our criminal justice system. Concerns about the near disappearance of criminal jury trials have been elevated as a result of numerous reports over the past decade highlighting the negative effects that coerced pleas have on both criminal defendants and the public’s oversight of prosecutors and law enforcement. In 2013, Human Rights Watch (HRW) published “An Offer You Can’t Refuse: How US Federal Prosecutors Force Drug Defendants to Plead Guilty,” which analyzed the trial penalty in federal drug cases. The report found that the “average sentence of federal drug offenders convicted after trial was three times higher (16 years) than that received after a guilty plea (5 years and 4 months).” 13 HRW attributed these harsh penalties and the overall disappearance of trials to the essentially unchecked discretion of prosecutors during the charging and plea offer phases and to “egregiously severe sentencing laws.” 14 The threat of such severe penalties after trial inevitably pressures criminal defendants to take pleas, 15 which has led to the virtual disappearance of criminal jury trials. 16 As one prosecutor bluntly stated: “The key function of the trial penalty is to encourage pleas.” 17 According to HRW, “this historically low rate of trials reflects an unbalanced and unhealthy criminal justice system.” 18 In July 2018, the NACDL identified similar issues in its report “The Trial Penalty: The Sixth Amendment Right to Trial on the Verge of Extinction and How to Save It.” The report found that federal criminal defendants in non-drug prosecutions—even those who were actually innocent—were frequently coerced into pleading guilty because the potential penalty associated with exercising their constitutional right

to trial was simply too great. According to the report, as of 2018, a trial “now occurs in less than 3% of state and federal criminal cases.” NACDL found that additional factors contributed to the disappearance of the trial, including prosecutorial discretion, informational inequalities between prosecutors and defendants, rigid federal Sentencing Guidelines and an inability or unwillingness on the part of judges to exercise their discretion at sentencing. While the promise of a lesser sentence is a potentially appropriate aspect of the plea negotiation process, “the gap between post-trial and post-plea sentences can be so wide” that it acts as an “overwhelming influence in a defendant’s consideration of a plea deal.” The report also noted that the immense pressure to plead guilty allows prosecutors to convince criminal defendants to agree to “all-or-nothing agreements,” which waive important rights like the ability to challenge the legality of the evidence obtained against them. In March 2021, NACDL and the New York State Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers (“NYSACDL”) published a report on the trial penalty in New York State, “The New York State Trial Penalty: The Constitutional Right to Trial Under Attack,” which included a survey of more than three hundred criminal defense attorneys from across the state and a statistical analysis of a sample of 79 criminal convictions in Manhattan. The report found that 94% of practitioners in the state agreed that the trial penalty plays a role in criminal practice in New York State, and that the trial penalty manifested in longer sentences after trial compared to earlier plea offers, with defendants being forced to waive various appellate rights and the ability to challenge the government’s case through motion practice to obtain more favorable pleas. The data analysis supported the observations of practitioners, showing that in 66% of defendants in the sample experienced a trial penalty and that increased plea offers were associated with increased eventual sentences (e.g., a plea offer of 5 years was associated, after conviction at trial, with a sentence of 7.5 years and a plea offer of 20 years was associated with a sentence of 28 years). The report also found that the trial penalty is driven by numerous factors, including prosecutorial practices such as aggressive charging, judicial pressure to plead guilty, and the prospect

12

THE CALIFORNIA TRIAL PENALTY: The Constitutional Right to Trial Under Attack 

Made with FlippingBook Online document maker