2026 NYC Parent Survey: What Child Care Parents Want

New Practice Lab at New America and Robin Hood partnered with NORC at the University of Chicago and the Mayor’s Office of Child Care and Early Education to launch the largest representative survey of New York City parents with young children to date. This report reveals what we learned.

The 2026 New York City Parent Survey: WHAT CHILD CARE PARENTS WANT October 2026

THE 2026 NEW YORK CITY PARENT SURVEY : WHAT CHILD CARE PARENTS WANT 1

TABLE OF CONTENTS

1. Foreword..................................................................................... 3

2. Executive Summary....................................................................... 4

3. Introduction..................................................................................7

4. Findings......................................................................................9

5. Policy Implications.......................................................................31

6. Conclusion.................................................................................34

7. Acknowledgements......................................................................35

8. Appendix I: Survey Methodology....................................................36

9. Appendix II: Study Limitations.......................................................37

THE 2026 NEW YORK CITY PARENT SURVEY : WHAT CHILD CARE PARENTS WANT 2

FOREWORD Mayor Mamdani announced this year that he was expanding child care to make it universal for New York City families. This announcement builds on the de Blasio Administration’s work beginning in 2014 to offer universal pre-kindergarten to all four-year-olds, followed by the launch of 3-K for three-year- olds, as well as the significant State expansions in child care assistance under Governor Hochul.

Still, thousands of families receive no public support in accessing high-quality early childhood educa- tion and care.

The success of universal child care in New York City will depend not only on reaching every family, but on designing a system that meets families’ needs. As two former public sector leaders — one at City Hall, helping to lead New York City’s rollout of 3-K and Pre-K For All, and one at The White House helping to advance the largest expansion of access to health care through the Affordable Care Act — we know that the first months of implementing any new initiative are critical. Understanding par- ents’ needs upfront is paramount. So, this project started with a simple idea: what would it look like for families to have a voice in shaping the future of child care in the City? Over the last several months, our teams launched the largest representative survey of New York City parents with young children, analyzed thousands of survey responses, and briefed dozens of govern- ment leaders across every City office and agency focused on child care. This effort brought together a rare combination of child care policy and implementation experts in and outside of government, data scientists and survey experts, human-centered design researchers, and philanthropy. To the thousands of parents and caregivers who took the time to share their experiences with us, thank you. We aim to amplify your voices and preferences to City leaders. We hope that creating this link between New Yorkers and their government will help policymakers enact decisions that are more responsive to the needs of families like yours. When we start by listening, especially to those who face greater barriers to being heard, and design policies in response to what we learn, we are more likely to build services that people can actually access and use. We can achieve real outcomes that matter and increase trust in the government’s capacity to deliver real results for people.

Richard R. Buery, Jr. Chief Executive Officer, Robin Hood

Tara Dawson McGuinness Founder and Executive Director, New Practice Lab

THE 2026 NEW YORK CITY PARENT SURVEY : WHAT CHILD CARE PARENTS WANT 3

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Earlier this year, the New Practice Lab at New America and Robin Hood partnered with NORC at the University of Chicago and the Mayor’s Office of Child Care and Early Education to launch the largest representative survey of New York City parents with young children to date. As the Mamdani Adminis- tration has made universal access to child care a cornerstone of its policy agenda, understanding exactly what care parents want — and when they want it — is critical, as is ensuring that families have a voice in shaping this ambitious effort. The survey, completed by 4,306 parents with children under six from every neighborhood across the city, was designed to answer questions central to the successful im- plementation of universal child care, including parents’ child care preferences and priorities, ideal care schedules, parental leave preferences, and awareness of existing programs. 1 Here is what we learned: g  Parents use many types of child care — and care is a 24/7 issue. 64 percent of NYC parents with children under six regularly use some form of nonparental child care. 2 Parents use a mix of child care arrangements, but care provided by a relative is most common followed by a child care center. Forty percent of parents are using care during “nontraditional” hours — weekday evenings and nights, or on weekends. g  Nearly half of parents don’t have the type of care they want. The current system underserves par- ents, and leaves them constrained for choice. Nearly half, or 47 percent, of parents do not have the type of child care they most want. And overall, 39 percent of parents say they have less child care than they need. g  Parents have different child care preferences and those preferences change based on a child’s age. When asked about the type of care they would most want at different ages, parents would over- whelmingly prefer for a parent to primarily provide care during their child’s first year; only 13 percent want a formal arrangement (school-based, center-based, or family day care). By age two, preferenc- es for formal arrangements and informal arrangements, such as care provided by a parent, relative or nanny, are roughly even. And at three, 69 percent of parents most want a formal child care setting, usually in a school. 3 g  The demand for formal child care varies by neighborhood. The share of parents preferring school- based, center-based, or family day care programs varies significantly by school district, with high- er shares of parents in generally higher-income districts in Manhattan and Brooklyn favoring such programs. At age two, preference for formal settings ranges from less than one-third of parents in Districts 19 (East New York) and 10 (Fordham, Riverdale) to over 65 percent in Districts 15 (Park Slope), 14 (Williamsburg, Greenpoint), and 32 (Bushwick), indicating that interest in 2-K seats could be uneven across districts. 1  Throughout this report, we use the terms “moms,” “dads,” and “parents” for readability. Those surveyed include biological parents, stepparents, adop- tive parents, foster parents, caregivers like grandparents, aunts, uncles, or siblings, legal guardians, and other caregivers with dependents under the age of six. 2 “Non-parental care” refers to regular child care provided by someone other than the respondent or the child’s other parent, including relatives, non-relatives and formal providers such as family day care, child care centers, school-based programs, and teachers or educators. 3 “Formal settings” includes care provided by a child care center, school-based program such as pre-K, or family day care/home-based child care program. Program sizes vary; pre-K programs can have multiple classrooms in a large building, and can be operated by a private community-based organization or the NYC Department of Education, while home-based programs operate in residential settings and are licensed to serve a smaller number of children.

THE 2026 NEW YORK CITY PARENT SURVEY : WHAT CHILD CARE PARENTS WANT 4

g  Most parents wanted longer parental leave than they had. If money and job security were not concerns, four in five parents would have wanted more time off than they had. On average, parents want five to six months, compared to the three or fewer months most leave takers actually used. Of those parents who took leave, only 55 percent used paid leave the entire time. The lowest-income working parents (those below 100 percent of the federal poverty level (FPL)) are even less likely to use paid leave, with 42 percent taking only unpaid leave. 4 g  Parents paying for child care are spending nearly $20,000 a year on average. Among parents with child care expenses, parents report spending an average of $1,621 per month on care for their children under six, with higher costs for younger children. Parents enrolled in 3-K, Pre-K, Child Care Assistance Program (CCAP, or child care vouchers), or Head Start spend meaningfully less on child care compared to parents not enrolled in public programs. For instance, those participat- ing in CCAP save as much as 61 percent on average. g  Awareness gaps may limit the reach of existing public programs. While familiarity with 3-K and Pre-K is high relative to other programs, there are still significant gaps in awareness of govern- ment benefits that can help offset child care costs, particularly among Hispanic and Asian Amer- ican Pacific Islander (AAPI) parents, non-English speaking parents, and lower-income parents in households below 200 percent of the federal poverty level. Awareness of the recently expanded Empire State Child Credit (ESCC), which is the State's child tax credit, is especially low with 58 per- cent of all parents saying they are unfamiliar or have never heard of it. g  Above all factors, trust in their child’s caregiver matters most. When choosing a child care pro- vider, trust ranks first in importance across nearly every demographic group, above the location of the provider and cost. Trust is especially important for parents of younger children. More than half (56 percent) of parents with infants selected trust compared to 38 percent of parents whose youngest child is four. Parents also care about many measures of quality. Beyond health and safe- ty, a roughly equal share of parents believe educator credentials, opportunities for outdoor play, small class sizes, and a focus on school readiness are important. g  Addressing cost and flexibility would make the biggest difference. Nearly four in ten parents with children under six cited some variation of greater affordability as the change to child care that would help their family most: lower costs, free or universal child care, or increased financial assistance. The second most common theme that emerged was related to greater flexibility. More than one in ten (11 percent) parents cite extended or more flexible hours of care, such as coverage for after-school hours, part-time care, evenings, and weekends.

4 In this report, “lower-income” refers to parents in households with incomes below 200 percent of the federal poverty level (FPL), equivalent to an annu- al income of $64,300 for a family of four. “Lowest-income” refers specifically to households below 100 percent FPL, equivalent to an annual income of $32,150 for a family of four.

THE 2026 NEW YORK CITY PARENT SURVEY : WHAT CHILD CARE PARENTS WANT 5

Parents' child care experiences and preferences underscore the need for greater public support while also making clear that there is no one-size-fits-all solution. The path forward is not a single program but a unified system flexible enough to meet the needs of New York’s families, whose lives and wishes vary. As New York City deploys new child care investments, the survey findings point toward several takeaways for government leaders to consider:

1. Make paid parental leave part of the universal child care strategy.

2. Expand access to publicly funded child care to match families’ varying needs:

g  Explore more flexible 2-K and 3-K options, including extended-day, part-time, evening, and weekend care. g Support informal care arrangements within a universal system. 3. Invest in multilingual, multicultural outreach and programming to build greater awareness and trust in publicly-funded care. Universal child care is more likely to succeed if it is built to give parents what they need, rather than what the existing systems can most easily provide. That means multiple City agencies that oversee individual pieces of the system will need to align around this shared vision. New York City has the opportunity now to change the lives of thousands of families and serve as a model for the nation of what it looks like to deliver for parents with young children.

THE 2026 NEW YORK CITY PARENT SURVEY : WHAT CHILD CARE PARENTS WANT 6

INTRODUCTION More than a decade ago, New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio launched Pre-K for All, mak- ing free pre-kindergarten available to every four-year-old in New York City regardless of family income. In the years since, the City has gradually expanded pre-kindergarten access to three-year-olds through 3-K, reaching roughly 45,000 three-year-olds (of just under 100,000 total) as of Fiscal Year 2025. 5 Under Governor Kathy Hochul, New York State has also significantly expanded child care assistance and investment. Yet families still face prohibitive costs and a limited patchwork of care options during the years be- fore pre-kindergarten and outside the traditional school day. Across the United States, public investment in child care remains limited, with most assistance targeted to fami- lies with the lowest incomes, and even then, reaching only a fraction of income-eligible households. Recognizing the significant financial strain that child care places on fami- lies with young children, Mayor Zohran Mamdani entered office at the start of 2026 with a commitment to provide universal child care for all New York City children under five years old. Building on the City’s existing publicly-funded child care programs, including Pre-K, 3-K, and child care vouchers, the Mamdani Administration announced in January that the phased-in implementation of universal child care would begin in September 2026 with an expansion of 3-K seats as well as new fully subsidized seats for two-year- olds through a new program called 2-K. 6 This effort, and the longer path to true universal access for all children under five, will be a signifi- cant operational undertaking. Of the roughly 480,000 children ages zero to four in New York City, it is estimated that hundreds of thousands are not enrolled in any publicly-funded care. 7 Expanding access to high-quality, affordable care for those who want it will require sizable new public investments over time, as well as careful planning to address challenges related to both supply and demand. De- spite improvements in data collection and reporting, the City has lacked data on what families actu- ally want. Fundamental questions about demand have — until now — gone unanswered, such as how many New York City parents want child care, and where and when do they want it? What type of care do parents with two-year-olds want? How about parents with children who are not yet two? Answering these questions — understanding what families’ true needs and preferences are — is critical to the success of a universal agenda. To help answer these questions and ensure the implementation of universal child care is both effective and responsive to NYC parents and caregivers across the five boroughs, the New Practice Lab at New

5 https://www.nyc.gov/assets/operations/downloads/pdf/pmmr2026/doe.pdf 6 https://www.nyc.gov/mayors-office/news/2026/01/mayor-mamdani---governor-hochul-to-launch-free-child-care-for-tw  7 Author’s analysis of U.S. Census American Community Survey data and data maintained by the Citizens’ Committee for Children of New York, available at https://data.cccnewyork.org/data/map/1316/enrollment-in-publicly-funded-care-for-children-under-5#1316/a/3/1536/131/a/a.

THE 2026 NEW YORK CITY PARENT SURVEY : WHAT CHILD CARE PARENTS WANT 7

America and Robin Hood partnered with NORC at the University of Chicago to conduct the largest rep- resentative survey to date of NYC parents and caregivers with children under six. 8 Developed in collab- oration with the Mayor’s Office for Child Care and Early Childhood Education, the roughly 50-question survey covered a range of topics: current child care arrangements and schedules, awareness of exist- ing programs, views on and priorities related to child care quality, parental leave (both paid and unpaid) experiences and preferences, and ideal child care arrangements and schedules. Over the course of three weeks in the spring of 2026, 4,306 parents and caregivers completed the survey. When weight- ed, the survey is representative of all NYC parents with at least one child under six. 9 This report reflects a comprehensive, though not exhaustive, overview of what we learned.

8 https://www.nyc.gov/mayors-office/news/2026/03/mayor-mamdani-launches-universal-child-care-parent-survey. 9 See Appendix I: Survey Methodology for details.

THE 2026 NEW YORK CITY PARENT SURVEY : WHAT CHILD CARE PARENTS WANT 8

FINDINGS Many parents with young children in New York City share similar child care challenges. Cost, limited access, and inflexibility are significant barriers. But not all parents have the same needs or vision for their children’s earliest years, with different preferences in terms of caregivers, schedules, and quali- ties. Some parents need support after the school day ends, others need care in the evenings or over- night, while some are seeking care only two or three days a week or would like a trusted relative to be paid to provide regular care. For many, current child care arrangements fall short of what they want or what they would ideally choose. These gaps are not evenly distributed across demographic lines — or the city itself. Parents use many types of child care — and care is a 24/7 issue. Today, 64 percent of NYC parents with children under six regularly use some form of nonparental child care. Parents who are currently employed are twice as likely as those who are not employed or retired to depend on someone else to care for their children. Among parents using nonparental care, 27 per- cent rely on care provided by a relative other than a parent, making it the most common arrangement, followed by child care centers at 22 percent (Figure 1). 10 Patterns of child care use also vary by race and ethnicity, income, and geography. Forty percent of His- panic parents rely on care provided by another relative. Use of relative care is also high among parents living in the Bronx (40 percent) and Staten Island (44 percent), while child care center use is higher among white parents (32 percent) and parents living in Brooklyn (30 percent). Parents with lower or more moderate incomes (less than 85 percent of the state median income (SMI)) are more likely to rely on care from another relative, while higher-income parents (above 85 percent SMI) are more likely to use child care centers.

10 The term “work” is used here to refer to formal employment or work for wages, as opposed to parents’ unpaid labor.

THE 2026 NEW YORK CITY PARENT SURVEY : WHAT CHILD CARE PARENTS WANT 9

Figure 1: Current Child Care Share of Parents Using Each Type of Nonparental Child Care Figure 1

Relative

27%

Child care center

22%

School-based program

15%

Family day care

14%

Nanny/au pair

10%

Other non-relative

9%

Combination (2 or more)

11%

0%

5%

10%

15%

20% 25% 30%

Notes: Source: Robin Hood Source: Survey of 4,306 parents and caregivers of children ages 0-5 living in New York City; conducted by NORC for New America’s New Practice Lab and Robin Hood, March 31-April 20, 2026. Note: Based on responses from 3,070 parents who regularly have someone beside a parent care for any of their children under six years old. Regularly was defined as care used weekly, and not occasional babysitting. “Combination (2 or more)” reflects parents who chose the response option “Combination of these options” for at least one child, indicating that at least one of their children utilizes more than one type of nonparental child care.

Roughly one in ten parents (11 percent) regularly use a combination of child care arrangements. Based on free-response answers (reviewed and categorized by NORC) to a question about how par- ents combine arrangements, 31 percent combine a school-based program with separate after-school care; nearly one in four (23 percent) use formal settings some days and informal settings on others; 18 percent of parents depend on grandparents alongside another form of care; and 14 percent have a separate caregiver who handles drop-offs and pick-ups. 11 Parents’ free-response survey answers un- derscore that many families are piecing together multiple care arrangements to cover the hours they need care; for some parents, this is driven by necessity as no single child care option is meeting all their needs, while others prefer having access to different providers to meet different needs. It is not just child care settings that vary but also care schedules, and the survey makes clear that child care is not only a Monday-through-Friday concern. Among parents who use nonparental care, 28 percent regularly use child care on Saturday, and one in three (33 percent) do so on Sunday. Saturday evening is a common window for parents who report having regular but non-daytime work sched- ules. 12 Parents who use child care on weekends are more likely to rely on relatives, nannies, friends, neighbors, or other non-relatives.

11 For the purpose of this report, the terms “formal child care” or “formal settings” are used to describe child care centers, family child care or home- based programs (licensed care provided in residential settings), and school-based programs such as Pre-K. The terms “informal child care” or “informal settings” are used here to describe care provided by a relative, nanny/au pair, or other non-relative such as a friend, neighbor, or other non-licensed caregiver. 12 Survey respondents were not asked about their occupation or the industry in which they work, but some industries, including hospitality, the arts, and medicine, regularly necessitate weekend evening and overnight hours.

THE 2026 NEW YORK CITY PARENT SURVEY : WHAT CHILD CARE PARENTS WANT 10

“I am a single parent and really struggling. I work Sunday through Thursday at a hospital and have been struggling with Sundays. My work has been letting me use my vacation days since I went back to work after short term disability and after paid family leave, but there are no daycares open on Sundays and I can’t afford a dedicated babysitter for Sundays.” Parent of a one-year-old living in Brooklyn For those parents who are using nonparental care on weekdays, full-day care (e.g., 8:00 am to 6:00 pm) is the most common, used by 44 to 49 percent of parents depending on the weekday. The next most common weekday schedule is equivalent to school-day hours (e.g., 8:00 am to 3:00 pm), with be- tween 26 and 30 percent using care during that window rather than a typical workday. Another one in ten parents are using care for a half day (e.g., 8:00 am to 12:00 pm). Five to six percent report regularly using care in the evenings and two to three percent use overnight care, depending on the day. While care provided outside of 9-to-5 Monday through Friday has typically been considered “nontra- ditional hours,” NYC parents’ experiences suggest these hours are not uncommon. Forty percent of parents are using care during these hours. Parents who do depend on nonparental care during these times are more likely to use informal arrangements. “I need longer, more flexible hours for childcare centers — like 7 AM to 7 PM, year-round, including summer and holidays. Most programs only run 8 AM — 2 PM during the school year, which doesn’t fit full-time jobs or overtime. If centers offered extended hours and summer care, I wouldn’t have to scramble for backup care or miss work.” Mom of a four-year-old living in Queens Nearly half of parents don’t have the type of care they want — and four in 10 have unmet care needs. Until now, it has not been known, beyond anecdotal evidence, whether parents’ utilization of child care reflects what they want versus what is available to them. This survey suggests that, for many families, current arrangements do not align with their ideal care arrangements. Overall, 47 percent do not have the type of child care they would most want at their child’s current age. The greatest misalignment occurs among parents using nonparental care for children under one who would largely prefer paren- tal care, and among parents who are caring for their three-year-old children themselves, who instead want formal care (Figure 2). Parents using formal care for their two- or three-year-olds are the most satisfied.

THE 2026 NEW YORK CITY PARENT SURVEY : WHAT CHILD CARE PARENTS WANT 11

Parents Not Using Their Preferred Type of Care, by Child’s Age and Current Child Care Figure 2 Figure 2: Mismatch - Current vs Ideal

Parental care Informal care Formal care

10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%

87%

80%

67%

64%

62%

60%

50%

38%

33%

24%

12%

9%

0%

Under Age 1

Age 1

Age 2

Age 3

Source: Survey of 4,306 parents and caregivers of children ages 0-5 living in New York City; conducted by NORC for New America’s New Practice Lab and Robin Hood, March 31-April 20, 2026. Note: For each type of current arrangement (categorized as parents using parental care, informal care, or formal care), the share of parents who would prefer to be using a different type of child care at each given age is shown.

Notes: Source: Robin Hood

Overall, 39 percent of parents say they have less child care than they actually need and that unmet need varies in some cases significantly across demographic lines. Roughly half of parents who primar- ily speak Spanish at home report needing more care. Unmet need is similarly high among parents who have irregular work schedules, and parents with household income below 100 percent of the federal poverty level. There are also higher rates of unmet need among Black, Hispanic, and AAPI parents; women (46 percent compared to 30 percent of men); and unemployed parents (45 percent versus 37 percent of working parents). Of the 16 percent of parents overall who say at least one of their children under six has a known or suspected developmental delay or disability, more than half (55 percent) report having less child care than they need; this is 20 percentage points higher than parents whose children do not have a known or suspected developmental delay or disability who are more likely to say the amount of child care they have generally meets their needs. 13

13 Review of a nationally representative sample of children born in the US in 2001 indicated that approximately 13% of children in the sample had devel- opmental delays that would make them eligible for Part C Early Intervention. Eligibility criteria for Early Intervention (EI) vary from state to state and may have an impact on access to EI services. Some states, like New York, require a moderate degree of delay in 2 or more domains of development or a severe delay in one domain in order to be found eligible, so some children with mild delays may not receive EI services. Stigma around the label of “developmental delay”, concern that this label, even if no longer applicable, may follow a child through their entire educational career, and cultural differences in the recognition and acceptance of developmental delays also play a role in EI uptake. See: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18504295/

THE 2026 NEW YORK CITY PARENT SURVEY : WHAT CHILD CARE PARENTS WANT 12

Child care preferences change based on the child’s age. New York City parents do not all want the same child care arrangements or early childhood experiences for their children. Some prefer larger settings where children can socialize in groups with other kids, while others favor more individualized care. Many parents would also want to combine arrangements; 44 percent said they would ideally use another type of child care alongside the setting they most want (for example, a parent and a relative). One striking finding, however, is that parents’ child care prefer- ences are not static, shifting significantly as children grow. 14 In other words, what parents most want for an infant differs from their ideal set-up for a three-year-old. While this may intuitively reflect children’s developmental needs at different stages of early childhood, this is the first time that the demand in NYC for different types of care at different ages has been measured. As shown in Figure 3, during their child’s first year, parental care is the overwhelming preference, with 69 percent selecting this arrangement. 15 Care from another relative is a distant second choice at 13 percent, though 43 percent of parents who want a combination of child care options at this age select- ed parental and relative care. Only 13 percent identify formal care as their preferred arrangement for a child under age one. At age one, the share preferring formal care more than doubles to 27 percent, while the preference for parental care drops from 69 percent to 40 percent, still the top choice, fol- lowed by care from another relative at 23 percent. “After going through this, especially as a nursing parent, I see how crucial the first year is and how dependent a child is on building their attachment systems. In a perfect world I would love to afford at least a year off (or work very part-time), with myself and family caregivers really until around 15 months after which the kid is usually walking, more independent and more interested in social relationships with peers. Even with two self employed parents this is not possible finan- cially or logistically.” Mom of a two-year-old living in Brooklyn

14 This aligns with the child care findings from the New Practice Lab’s 2026 National Parent Survey: https://www.newamerica.org/insights/2026-nation- al-parent-survey/ 15  Parents were asked what child care arrangement they would most want to have and provided with the following response options: Yourself/other parent, Family member/relative, Non-relative, Family day care or home-based program, Child care center, and School-based program.

THE 2026 NEW YORK CITY PARENT SURVEY : WHAT CHILD CARE PARENTS WANT 13

Figure 1: High-need New Yorkers experience housing hardship at higher rates than non-high-need New Yorkers. (Copy) Parents’ Child Care Preferences for Each Age Group Figure 3

School-based program Child care center Non-relative (e.g.,friend, neighbor, or nanny)

Family day care/home-based program

Family member/relative Myself/other parent

5% 5% 6% 1%

100%

3%

11%

90%

15%

Lorem ipsum

38%

80%

23%

10%

13%

70%

8%

60%

16%

23%

19%

50%

6%

69%

40%

13%

19%

30%

12% 4%

20%

40%

23%

10%

13%

0%

Under Age 1

Age 1

Age 2

Age 3

Source: Survey of 4,306 parents and caregivers of children ages 0-5 living in New York City; conducted by NORC for New America’s New Practice Lab and Robin Hood, March 31-April 20, 2026. Note: All parents were asked to consider the type of child care they would most want at each given age, imagining they could design their ideal situation. Parents were presented with definitions of each type. Percentages do not total 100 at each age due to a small share of respondents skipping the question.

High-Need

It is not until age two, as shown in Figure 4, that parents’ preferences are roughly evenly divided be- tween formal child care and more informal arrangements such as a parent, relative, or nanny. At this age, more parents describe more openness to and desire for group socialization and a formal early education environment. The preference for formal settings only grows at age three, at which point school-, center-, and home-based programs are firmly preferred over informal settings. At three, school-based programs are parents’ top choice at 37 percent, consistent with the fact that parents are at that age also more likely to prioritize structured learning over free play. Not High-Need

THE 2026 NEW YORK CITY PARENT SURVEY : WHAT CHILD CARE PARENTS WANT 14

Figure 4: Formal vs. Informal By Age

Share of Parents Who Most Want Formal or Informal Arrangements at Each Age Figure 4

Formal arrangements Informal arrangements

87%

100%

70%

87%

69%

80%

70%

69%

49%

60%

49%

48%

40%

30%

30%

27%

20%

13%

13%

0%

Under Age 1

Age 1

Age 2

Age 3

As preference for formal child care increases through early childhood, so does the amount of nonpa- rental care parents want. Among those parents who most want a formal setting, the share of parents seeking full-day care or care on all weekdays steadily increases from infancy through age three. Under age one, 48 percent want a full day of child care and 67 percent want care all weekdays, while at age three, 55 percent want a full day and 81 percent want care on all weekdays. “A few days a week of morning care, and the occasional longer day with a sitter, is a great way to maintain balance and give our kids developmentally appropriate experiences in early childhood. I wish all families had this choice! The most challenging part is that the cost of part time care can- cels out part-time earnings. I hope that universal childcare will fund part time spots for toddlers and that policy will change to allow for part time 3-K so that children can spend more time with their families when possible, while still benefiting from a structured group experience.” Mom of three children living in Queens Source: Survey of 4,306 parents and caregivers of children ages 0-5 living in New York City; conducted by NORC for New America’s New Practice Lab and Robin Hood, March 31-April 20, 2026. Note: Parents were asked to select the child care option they would want to use most often in a typical week. “Formal arrangements” represents parents who stated they most want a family day care or home-based program, child care center, or school-based pro- gram. “Informal arrangements” represents those parents who selected myself/other parent, family member/relative, or non-relative (e.g., friend, neighbor, nanny). Percentages do not total 100 at each age due to a small share of respondents skipping the question. Notes: Source: Robin Hood

THE 2026 NEW YORK CITY PARENT SURVEY : WHAT CHILD CARE PARENTS WANT 15

Likelihood Parents Who Want Informal Care Would Accept Free Formal Care, by Setting Type Figure 5 Many parents who prefer an informal child care arrangement say that it is important to them that their child be around family, and some are hesitant to use caregivers they do not know personally or settings where they may have limited visibility. Even so, some parents who did not select formal care would be open to using a school-, center-, or home-based program if a seat were offered to their child at no cost. Depending on the setting, 37 to 51 percent of parents who did not initially prefer formal care say they would be very or extremely likely to enroll their child in a school-, center, or home-based setting if offered at no cost (Figure 5). Overall, analysis of the data suggests that availability of free programming could increase the use of formal care by an additional 14 percent of parents beyond those who already identified it as their preferred arrangement. Figure 5: Formal Inducement “Myself, a relative, or close trusted friend caring for my child in the first 2 years of life is ideal because I feel comfortable and have a relationship with the person caring for them. By 3 years old I would like my child to start experiencing what school is like and socializing more with other children, but 3-K could be part time with friend/family caring for him the rest of the time.” Mom of one child under one living in Queens

Extremely/very likely Not very/not likely at all

60%

51%

42%

40%

37%

27%

24%

20%

16%

0%

School-based program

Child care center

Family day care or home-based program

Notes: Source: Sources Source: Survey of 4,306 parents and caregivers of children ages 0-5 living in New York City; conducted by NORC for New America’s New Practice Lab and Robin Hood, March 31-April 20, 2026. Note: Based on responses from 724 parents who did not select any formal arrangement—family day care or home-based program, child care center, or school-based program—as the arrangement they most want for any age group (under 1, age 1, age 2, or age 3). These parents were asked how likely they would be to actually use each of these types of care (family day care or home-based program, child care center, or school-based program) if a space in that setting was available to them at no cost. Parents who selected “Somewhat likely” are not shown.

THE 2026 NEW YORK CITY PARENT SURVEY : WHAT CHILD CARE PARENTS WANT 16

Overall, 92 percent of parents in NYC with young children either prefer or are open to utilizing formal child care at some point from infancy to age three. 16 But only 15 percent identify formal care as their preferred arrangement at every age, underscoring that most parents want access to different forms of care, including familial and other, informal arrangements, during the infant and toddler years. Demand for formal settings is uneven across the city. The share of parents who prefer formal child care at each age can give an indication of potential de- mand for these settings across early childhood, including the share of parents who would be likely to participate in 2-K when fully phased in. Citywide figures, however, can obscure meaningful differences across neighborhoods. Because the Mamdani Administration plans to roll out 2-K by adding seats in individual school districts over time, NORC also developed small area estimates at the school district level for select survey responses. These estimates offer a window into the approximate need for li- censed seats in each district (See Appendix I for further details on methods). The findings demonstrate that preferences for formal settings vary significantly across the city. On average, school- or center-based care is a more popular top choice among parents in high income dis- tricts in neighboring parts of Brooklyn and Manhattan (Brooklyn Heights, Greenpoint/Williamsburg, the Financial District, and the Upper East Side) than in the Bronx or Southeast Queens. For two-year- olds, the share of parents preferring school- or center-based care ranges from just 18 percent in Bronx School District 10 (Fordham, Riverdale) to 52 percent in Brooklyn School District 14 (Williamsburg, Greenpoint). Demand for home-based care is lower than demand for centers and schools, and more mixed geographically, with pockets of Queens and Brooklyn claiming the highest demand among all districts. Combined, the share of parents preferring formal settings at age two ranges from 33 percent in Brooklyn School District 19 (East New York) to 69 percent in Brooklyn School District 32 (Bushwick). Among the five districts in which the first 2-K seats are being offered — 6, 10, 18, 23, and 27 — the per- centages of parents who want a formal seat at age two fall in the bottom half of districts, ranging be- tween 33 percent in District 10 (Fordham, Riverdale) to 45 percent in District 6 (Washington Heights). 17

16 Parents are considered to be open to utilizing formal child care if they most want informal care but note that they would be very or extremely likely to use formal care if this arrangement was offered to them at no cost. Parents are considered to prefer formal care if it is either their top choice, or chosen as a part of their preferred combination. 17  The five districts in which the first 2-K seats are available are: District 6 — Inwood, Washington Heights (Manhattan), District 10 — Riverdale, Bedford Park, Norwood (Bronx), District 18 — Canarsie, East Flatbush (Brooklyn), District 23 — Brownsville, Ocean Hill (Brooklyn), and District 27 — Richmond Hill, Woodhaven, Howard Beach, South Ozone Park (Queens).

THE 2026 NEW YORK CITY PARENT SURVEY : WHAT CHILD CARE PARENTS WANT 17

Percent of NYC Parents By School District Who Prefer Center/School-Based Care For Their Children at Age 2

Percent of NYC Parents By School District Who Prefer Home-Based Care For Their Children at Age 2

Parents were asked to select the child care option they would want to use most often in a typical week. Source: Survey of 4,306 parents and caregivers of children ages 0-5 living in New York City; conducted by NORC for New America’s New Practice Lab and Robin Hood, March 31-April 20, 2026.

THE 2026 NEW YORK CITY PARENT SURVEY : WHAT CHILD CARE PARENTS WANT 18

Percent of NYC Parents By School District Who Prefer Center/School-Based Care or Home-Based Care For Their Children at Age 2

Parents were asked to select the child care option they would want to use most often in a typical week. Source: Survey of 4,306 parents and caregivers of children ages 0-5 living in New York City; conducted by NORC for New America's New Practice Lab, March 31 - April 20, 2026.

Parents want longer parental leave than they had. Recognizing that parental leave can shape whether parents are able to care for their children during the earliest months of life, the survey also asked parents about their experiences of parental leave after their youngest child was born — and how much leave they would like to have if money and job security were not concerns. Leave-taking varies significantly based on gender, household income, and race and ethnicity. But NYC parents with young children, irrespective of those same demographic charac- teristics, want more parental leave on average than they had — consistent with the finding that most want a parent to be their child’s primary caregiver during their first year. Overall, four in five parents would have wanted more leave than they had. Among parents who were employed when their youngest child was born, 86 percent took parental leave from work, while 14 percent did not. Lower-income parents (26 percent of parents with income below 200 percent of FPL compared to 9 percent of parents at or above that threshold), dads (20 per- cent compared to 8 percent of moms), Black, Hispanic, and AAPI parents (20 percent, 16 percent, and 14 percent, respectively, compared to 9 percent of white parents) were more likely to have not taken any parental leave following their child’s birth. Among those parents who did take parental leave, 55

THE 2026 NEW YORK CITY PARENT SURVEY : WHAT CHILD CARE PARENTS WANT 19

percent used only paid leave, 30 percent combined paid and unpaid leave, and 15 percent took un- paid leave (Figure 6a). While mothers and fathers were similarly likely to use paid versus unpaid leave, lower-income parents and Black, Hispanic, and AAPI parents were significantly more likely than high- er-income and white parents to take only unpaid leave. The lowest-income working parents (those Figure 6: Paid vs Unpaid Leave

Paid leave only Paid and unpaid leave Unpaid leave only Unp FPL) Unpaid leave only (100-199% FPL) Unpaid leave only (200% FP

below 100 percent of FPL) are significantly less likely than higher-income parents to use paid leave, with 42 percent taking only unpaid leave (Figure 6b). 18 Among those NYC parents who did take paid leave, the State’s Paid Family Leave program and employer-sponsored policies are the most commonly used types, with 65 percent of parents using the State program and 54 percent using their employer’s benefit. How- ever, more parents may be eligible for New York State Paid Family Leave (NYS PFL) than take it: 36 percent of parents who took leave other than NYS PFL reported that they were unaware of the program. Slightly more than one in three (35 percent) parents used vaca- tion time, about one in four (24 percent) used paid sick leave, and one in five (20 percent) used temporary disability insurance. 19 At 45 percent, Black parents were significantly more likely to have used paid vacation time (versus 33 percent of white parents), while white parents more often used an employ- er-sponsored paid leave policy (61 percent versus 50 percent of Black parents). Although New York State Paid Family Leave (NYS PFL) offers up to 12 weeks of job-protected leave, 28 percent of parents who used the program took less time than that. When this group was asked why they took less than 12 weeks, 31 percent shared that their work makes it hard to be away longer, while roughly one in four (24 percent) said they simply cannot afford financially to take a longer leave. New York’s 18 When asked why they did not take New York State Paid Family Leave, the most common responses of parents who took only unpaid leave were that they were not aware of it or did not think they were eligible. However, sample size is small for this subpopulation. 19 Percentages here do not total 100 percent as parents often stack multiple benefits and could select more than one response option.  30% 15% Unpaid leave only

55%

Leave Type Taken by Parents

60%

60%

55%

50%

50%

40%

40%

30%

30%

30%

20%

20%

15%

Figure 6: Paid vs Unpaid Leave

10%

10%

0% Paid leave only Paid and unpaid leave Unpaid leave only Unpaid leave only (<100% FPL) Unpaid leave only (100-199% FPL) Unpaid leave only (200% FPL+)

0%

Unpaid leave only

Paid leave only Paid and unpaid leave

55%

Use of Unpaid Leave Only, by Income

Notes: Source: Robin Hood 60%

60%

55%

50%

50%

42%

40%

40%

28%

30%

30%

20%

20%

8%

10%

10%

0%

0%

Unpaid leave only (<100% FPL)

Unpaid leave only (100- 199% FPL)

Unpaid leave only (200% FPL+)

Paid leave only Paid and unpaid leave

Note: Based on responses from 3,246 parents who took time off of work when their youngest child was born. Source: Survey of 4,306 parents and caregivers of children ages 0-5 living in New York City; conducted by NORC for New America's New Practice Lab and Robin Hood, March 31 - April 20, 2026.

Notes: Source: Robin Hood

THE 2026 NEW YORK CITY PARENT SURVEY : WHAT CHILD CARE PARENTS WANT 20

PFL law requires only a percentage (67 percent) of an employee’s average weekly wages be replaced while they are on leave. 20 Twenty-four percent of parents said that their employer asked them to return to work sooner than 12 weeks or that their employer or coworkers did not endorse an extended leave. “You only get paid a portion of pay 60% and I would not be able to support myself on that.” Mom of a two-year-old living in the Bronx Overall, across all leave types, whether paid or unpaid, two-thirds (66 percent) of NYC parents with young children took 12 weeks of leave or less after their youngest was born (Figure 7). However, differences emerge along demographic lines on leave duration as well. Nearly nine in ten (87 percent) dads took 12 weeks or less, while half (49 percent) of moms did and half of moms took longer leaves. Additionally, parents with income below 200 percent of FPL were more likely to take shorter leaves, with 19 percent taking two weeks or less compared to 11 percent of parents with income above 200 percent of FPL.

Figure 7: Leave Taken How Much Parental Leave Parents Took for Their Youngest Child Figure 7 30%

24%

25%

20%

116%

15%

113%

113%

9%

10%

8%

88%

7%

5%

0%

Less than 2 weeks

1 month 2 months 3 months 4 months 5 months 6 months 7 months or more

Notes: Source: Robin Hood Source: Survey of 4,306 parents and caregivers of children ages 0-5 living in New York City; conducted by NORC for New America’s New Practice Lab and Robin Hood, March 31-April 20, 2026. Note: Based on responses from 3,246 parents who took time off of work when their youngest child was born. “Less than 2 weeks” re- flects parents who selected “Less than a week” or “1-2 weeks.” “7 months or more” reflects parents who selected one of “7 months (25- 28 weeks),” “8 months (29-32 weeks),” “9 months (33-36 weeks),” “10 months (37-40 weeks),” “11 months (41-44 weeks),” “12 months (45-52 weeks),” or “Over 12 months.”

20  No state PFML program offers 100 percent wage replacement to all eligible workers. However, many state PFML programs provide higher wage replacement to lower-wage workers. In NY State, eligible workers receive 67 percent of their average weekly wage, up to 67 percent of the State Average Weekly Wage ($1,228.53 per week in 2026). New York’s flat rate is among the lowest of state paid leave programs, and it is the only state with a separate wage replacement rate for medical leave (known as Temporary Disability Insurance), which has been capped at $170 per week since 1989. https://www.newamerica.org/insights/explainer-paid-leave-benefits-and-funding-in-the-united-states/

THE 2026 NEW YORK CITY PARENT SURVEY : WHAT CHILD CARE PARENTS WANT 21

A meaningful gap exists between the amount of leave that parents took when their youngest was born and the amount of leave they would like to have if money and job security were not a concern: 42 percent of parents want six months or more, yet only 16 percent of parents took six months or more leave (Figure 8). On average, parents want five to six months. This citywide average is driven, in part, by a large share (21 percent) of parents who would prefer 12 months of leave or more. While preferred lengths of leave vary by different demographic characteristics — moms, for example, most often want- ed six months of leave, while dads most often wanted only three — the majority desire for more time holds true for parents regardless of gender, income, race and ethnicity. Parents’ preferences for longer lengths of leave are consistent with parents’ desire to be their child’s primary caregiver during their first year and with the well-documented health and economic benefits of parental leave on both par- ents and their children. 21

Figure 8: Leave Wanted

How Much Parental Leave Parents Want Figure 8

15%

8%

2 weeks or less

1 month

10%

2 months

9%

3 months

13%

4 months

7%

5 months

4%

14%

6 months

7-11 months

6%

15%

12 months

More than 12 months

6%

I would prefer not to return to paid work

4%

15%

0%

5%

10%

Source: Survey of 4,306 parents and caregivers of children ages 0-5 living in New York City; conducted by NORC for New America’s New Practice Lab and Robin Hood, March 31-April 20, 2026. Note: Parents were asked to consider how many weeks of family leave they would like to have after the birth or adoption of a child, if money and their job security were not a concern.

Notes: Source: Robin Hood

21  https://www.apa.org/monitor/2022/04/feature-parental-leave; https://pn3policy.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/PN3PIC_PaidFamilyMedicalLeave_ EvidenceReview_0925.pdf

THE 2026 NEW YORK CITY PARENT SURVEY : WHAT CHILD CARE PARENTS WANT 22

Page 1 Page 2 Page 3 Page 4 Page 5 Page 6 Page 7 Page 8 Page 9 Page 10 Page 11 Page 12 Page 13 Page 14 Page 15 Page 16 Page 17 Page 18 Page 19 Page 20 Page 21 Page 22 Page 23 Page 24 Page 25 Page 26 Page 27 Page 28 Page 29 Page 30 Page 31 Page 32 Page 33 Page 34 Page 35 Page 36 Page 37 Page 38

Made with FlippingBook flipbook maker