11
HERRERA ET AL .
TABLE 3
Results of the guideline search.
Database
Identified, potentially relevant guidelines
Critical appraisal
Guideline International Network (GIN) International Guidelines Library a The National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE) b
No thematically relevant hits
Not applicable
Focus on orofacial implants, therefore potentially relevant But: Data more than a decade old, does not directly address biological complications Not applicable Focus on orofacial implants, therefore potentially relevant But: Data more than a decade old, does not directly address biological complications Not applicable Focus on oral implants, therefore potentially relevant But: Data more than 15 years old, focus on palatal implants, does not directly address biological complications Not applicable Focus on oral implants, therefore potentially relevant But: Data more than 15 years old, focus on palatal implants, does not directly address biological complications Not applicable Does not readily address per-implant diseases Not applicable Does not readily address per-implant diseases Not applicable
Insertion of customized exposed titanium implants, without soft tissue cover, for complex orofacial reconstruction (Jul 2013)
Insertion of customized titanium implants, with soft tissue cover, for orofacial reconstruction (Jul 2013)
Soft-palate implants for simple snoring (Nov 2007)
Soft-palate implants for obstructive sleep apnoea (Nov 2007)
Guidelinecentral.com ‘ Dentistry ’ category
Antibiotic prophylaxis for prevention of prosthetic joint infection (Jan 2015) Prevention of orthopaedic implant infection in patients undergoing dental procedures (Dec 2012)
Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality c Canadian Health Technology Assessment (CADTH) d
No thematically relevant hits
Not applicable
Biological mesh: A review of clinical effectiveness, cost- effectiveness and guidelines — an update (Aug 2015)
Focus on implants in other areas, no direct relation to oral diseases Not applicable Focus on implants in other areas, no direct relation to oral diseases Not applicable Focus on dental implants in very specific, selected patient group, peri-implantitis not directly addressed, 7-year-old data Not applicable
Osseointegrated Prosthetic Implants for Lower Limb Amputation: A Review of Clinical Effectiveness, Cost- Effectiveness and Guidelines (Feb 2017) Immediate osseointegrated implants for cancer patients: A review of clinical and cost-effectiveness (Jan 2015)
EFP S3-level clinical practice guideline for stages I – III periodontitis EFP S3-level clinical practice guideline for stage IV periodontitis
European Federation of Periodontology (EFP) e
Indirectly applicable, high quality
Indirectly applicable, high quality
Focus on periodontal defects only — peri- implantitis not addressed Not applicable
American Academy of
AAP best evidence consensus: Biologics in clinical practice (Oct 2022)
Periodontology (AAP) f
AAP best evidence consensus: Periodontal phenotype (Jan 2020)
Focus on tissues around teeth, rather than dental implants Not applicable Potentially relevant: Two SRs address adjunctive laser use and photodynamic therapy, respectively, for peri- implant mucositis and peri-implantitis But: More than 4 years old, superseded by new SRs in current guideline Not directly applicable
AAP best evidence consensus: Laser therapy (Apr 2018)
(Continues)
Made with FlippingBook Annual report