Carrejo et al. Carbon Neutrality
(2026) 5:3
Page 2 of 35
1 Introduction Global warming, driven primarily by elevated atmos- pheric concentrations of carbon dioxide (CO 2 ), will require aggressive mitigation strategies across all sectors of the global economy to limit temperature rise to 1.5 °C or less by 2100, as projected by current climate models [1, 2]. These strategies fall into three complementary cat- egories: (1) reducing reliance on fossil fuels through the adoption of low-carbon and renewable energy sources; (2) preventing new CO 2 emissions via technologies such as carbon capture and storage (CCS); and (3) actively removing legacy CO 2 from the atmosphere through carbon dioxide removal (CDR) pathways. CDR refers to activities that remove CO 2 from the atmosphere, ensuring its durable storage as CO 2 or transformed into another stable form of carbon [3]. CDR excludes natu- rally occurring CO 2 uptake that lacks direct human or engineered intervention, and while it may incorporate carbon CCS technologies, it is distinguished by its focus on removing CO 2 already in the atmosphere—rather than capturing fossil emissions at point sources such as power plants or industrial facilities [3]. To achieve global net- zero emissions, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) highlights the critical need for large-scale CDR, estimating that between 350 and 1,200 gigatons of CO 2 must be removed from the atmosphere by 2100 to limit warming to 1.5 °C [4]. CDR projects are anticipated to fulfill several critical functions across different time- scales. In the short term, they are expected to contrib- ute to the reduction of net emissions. Over the medium term, CDR aims to counterbalance residual emissions from sectors where complete abatement is challenging or economically expensive (e.g., aviation, heavy industry, cement, chemicals, and agriculture), thereby facilitat- ing the achievement of net-zero emissions. In the longer term, CDR could potentially enable ‘net-negative’ emis- sions, where annual CO 2 removal exceeds emissions, to lower atmospheric CO 2 concentrations and contribute to global temperature reduction [5]. Biomass Carbon Removal and Storage (BiCRS) refers to the process of capturing and permanently storing carbon dioxide that was originally removed from the atmosphere via photosynthesis in plants. When biomass is industri- ally processed—such as in the pulp and paper sector—it releases biogenic CO 2 that, if captured and sequestered, can result in net atmospheric carbon removal. This is a form of BiCRS named Bioenergy with Carbon Cap- ture and Storage (BECCS). This removal is achieved when the quantity of biogenic CO 2 permanently stored exceeds the total greenhouse gas emissions (GHG) (in CO 2 -equivalent) generated across the life cycle of the bio- mass utilization process. For instance, Pratama et al. [6] evaluated the integration of BECCS into a polygeneration
system (BECCS-PS) for the co-production of green elec- tricity and methanol using palm oil empty fruit bunches as feedstock. The research compares two scenarios for producing renewable hydrogen—needed for methanol synthesis—using either solar photovoltaics (PV-PEM) or a geothermal power plant (GEO-PEM) as the power source. The findings reveal that both scenarios achieve negative CO 2 -equivalent emissions for electricity gen- eration. However, the process handles a lower amount of biomass compared to the pulp and paper industry, which represents one of the most promising industrial plat- forms for CDR at scale through BECCS. It emits more biogenic CO 2 from concentrated point sources—typi- cally ranging from 10% to 20% by volume [7, 8]— than any other industrial sector in the United States, including ethanol and biopower facilities. From a pulp and paper process point of view, the car- bon removed by biomass can be viewed in two forms: (1) temporary product storage: the carbon embodied in the final paper products, and (2) permanent geologi- cal storage: the capture of biogenic CO 2 emissions (e.g., from a recovery boiler) and its injection into deep geo- logical formations for permanent sequestration. This study mainly adopts a cradle-to-grave system boundary, in which paper products are ultimately decomposed at their end-of-life, releasing their stored carbon back to the atmosphere. Therefore, the temporary product storage does not contribute to a net carbon removal or BECCS/ BiCRS-based solution. Net atmospheric carbon removal is mainly achieved via permanent geological storage. Only under a dynamic LCA perspective is the effect of temporal carbon storage by the paper product included in this study. As a mature industry with well-established biomass supply chains, high-capacity steam and power systems, and relatively low fossil fuel dependency, pulp and paper mills offer a compelling opportunity for dura- ble CDR when integrated with CCS. In the United States alone, the pulp and paper industry emits approximately 110 million tonnes of biogenic CO 2 each year [8]— on average, about 1 million tonnes per virgin and recycled integrated mill—setting the upper limit for CDR potential from this sector if all of those emissions were captured and durably stored without any additional emissions to the atmosphere. Although there is a considerable poten- tial for CDR in the pulp and paper industry, its successful deployment will depend on overcoming key challenges— ranging from varying levels of technological readiness and high capital costs to the need for sustained financ- ing, supportive policy frameworks, and robust monitor- ing, reporting, and verification (MRV) systems. Robust lifecycle assessment as part of carbon market protocols is essential to ensure that claimed removals are real, addi- tional, and durable [9, 10]. Carbon removal credits have
Made with FlippingBook Online newsletter maker