Carrejo et al. Carbon Neutrality
(2026) 5:3
Page 3 of 35
Table 1 Comparison of system boundaries of current registry protocols of carbon removal credits from CCS projects Protocol Scope System Boundaries
General CCS projects (DAC and/or industrial CO 2 )
Encompasses all individual CCS module boundaries (capture, transport, storage). CO 2 captured from Bionergy (BECCS) ( gate-to-gate )
Verra [20]
BECCS, DACCS, and biogenic CO 2 sources; excludes fossil CO 2 From carbon stream capture to injection into a storage reservoir. Includes both embedded (infrastructure, land-use) and operational (energy, materials) emissions at each stage ( gate-to-grave )
Puro.earth [21]
Limited explicitly to carbon capture, processing, transport, and storage components of the BECCS system ( gate-to- grave ) Primarily " cradle-to-grave " GHG Statement (establishment, operations, end-of-life). "Narrow system boundary" ( gate-to- gate ) option for facilities with financially viable co-products or those in cap-and-trade systems, allowing exclusion of non- CCS-related emissions
EcoEngineers/Drax [22] CDR via power/heat BECCS using solid biomass fuels
Industrial biogenic CCS captured at a point source; excludes fossil CO 2
Isometric [23]
of bioethanol, it does not necessarily yield a net-nega- tive process [24, 25]. Voluntary carbon credit standards, such as those of Puro.earth and Gold Standard, use sys- tem boundaries that allow for carbon removal from corn ethanol; in 2024, Red Trail Energy became the first corn ethanol facility with CCS to sell such credits [26, 27]. This highlights an important tension in how carbon removal is assessed: traditional life cycle accounting prac- tices at biorefineries—such as those producing ethanol or pulp and paper—often treat biogenic CO 2 as a waste, jus- tifying a narrow system boundary that includes only the CCS plant. In contrast, some suggest that biogenic CO 2 may not qualify as waste, since its availability for capture is contingent on biomass cultivation, harvesting, trans- portation, and processing—activities that introduce addi- tional emissions. From this perspective, broader system boundaries may be important for more accurately assess- ing net carbon removal. This discrepancy in boundary assumptions has the potential to place dedicated, green- field BiCRS facilities—such as those focused solely on biomass burial—at a relative disadvantage. These facili- ties must account for emissions across the entire bio- mass supply chain in addition to the BiCRS process itself, whereas retrofitted biorefineries often only attribute emissions from the CCS unit, potentially overstating their net carbon removal when narrow boundaries are applied. At the same time, the use of narrow boundaries is not without merit: it aligns with long-standing LCA conven- tions in process industries, where gate-to-gate analyses are widely used to isolate unit operations, benchmark performance, and facilitate technology-to-technology comparisons. By focusing narrowly on the CCS unit, such assessments can provide clarity about process effi- ciency and aid early deployment, even without capturing all system-level effects. An interesting question arises for
been generated at pulp and paper mills through CCS pro- jects that capture biogenic CO 2 from recovery boiler flue gas [11]. Despite growing interest in CCS, its net carbon removal potential in the pulp and paper industry remains unquantified. More importantly, no studies have sys- tematically demonstrated how critical and sensitive the resulting carbon balance is to the definition of the LCA system boundaries. While previous studies have evalu- ated emissions from pulp and paper production [12–18], they have not assessed the net carbon removal potential of CCS integration under these varying boundary condi- tions. This study fills this methodological gap by present- ing a comprehensive GHG accounting of an amine-based CCS system in a pulp and paper mill, specifically evalu- ating carbon removal across multiple system boundary scenarios. This is critical, as some carbon removal tech- nologies may emit more CO 2 across the supply chain than they sequester [19]. Table 1 summarizes the system boundaries that current registry protocols use to ensure the integrity, effectiveness, and sustainability of CCS pro- jects, particularly those involving bioenergy with carbon capture and storage (BECCS) and direct air capture with carbon capture and storage (DACCS). In general, retrofit projects are evaluated under narrow (gate-to-gate) sys- tem boundaries. Not all biomass-based industries can achieve net-nega- tive emissions through CCS integration under commonly used system boundaries. For example, while retrofitting a corn ethanol plant to capture high-purity fermentation CO 2 can reduce life cycle GHG emissions by 30–40% [24], the upstream and downstream emissions from feed- stock cultivation, transport, processing, and fuel com- bustion often outweigh the biogenic CO 2 captured and stored. Thus, while CCS can improve the carbon intensity
Made with FlippingBook Online newsletter maker