PAPERmaking! Vol12 Nr2 2026

Carrejo et al. Carbon Neutrality

(2026) 5:3

Page 4 of 35

amine-based system CCS plant to a 462,000 air dry tonnes per year unbleached softwood kraft pulp mill (UBSK) in the southeastern U.S. LCA system bounda- ries are defined by their scope. A gate-to-gate boundary considers only the core production processes, excluding upstream or downstream emissions. A cradle-to-gate analysis expands this, accounting for all upstream emis- sions—such as resource exploitation, procurement, and raw material preparation—in addition to the production boundaries. Conversely, a gate-to-grave analysis includes the production phase and all subsequent downstream emissions, covering distribution, the use phase, and end-of-life disposal. Finally, the cradle-to-grave bound- ary is the most comprehensive, including all upstream, production, and downstream emissions for a product or service. This study independently analyzed the pulp and paper mill (yellow dashed line) and carbon capture facili- ties (red dashed line). Then, both systems were integrated (pink dashed line) under several sources of flue gases feeding the CCS plant to estimate the carbon removal obtained in such integration. This study evaluates the carbon removal potential of retrofitting a representative U.S. virgin kraft lin- erboard mill with an amine-based CCS system. The analysis is structured around five distinct system con- figurations, each designed to explore the influence of boundary assumptions and temporal carbon accounting approaches on the estimated removal efficiency: • System 1 (Baseline – Cradle-to-Gate): Baseline GHG emissions from the standalone paper mill (no CCS). The net carbon balance compares the CO 2 emissions from the process and the raw material supply chain against the total biogenic CO 2 fixed by the biomass feedstock during photosynthesis. • System 2 (Narrow Gate-to-Gate): Standalone CCS facility assessed from a static CDR perspective, treat- ing biogenic CO 2 as a “waste” stream, while excluding upstream emissions from biomass sourcing, onsite emissions from biomass processing, and downstream emissions from paper product decomposition. The maximum theoretical carbon removal is defined as the total quantity of biogenic CO 2 physically cap- tured in the CCS unit. • System 3 (Narrow Cradle-to-Gate): Paper mill and CCS facility assessed from a static CDR perspective, treating biogenic CO 2 as a co-product rather than a “waste” stream, and including onsite emissions from biomass processing and upstream emissions from biomass sourcing but excluding downstream emis- sions from paper product decomposition. The maxi- mum theoretical carbon removal is defined as the

retrofitted biorefineries: What happens when the value of capturing and sequestering biogenic CO 2 approaches or exceeds the value of the primary products, such as etha- nol or paper? This shifting economic dynamic—driven by the emerging value of carbon removal—has the potential to fundamentally reshape the role and design of exist- ing biorefineries, positioning them as carbon removal platforms rather than solely producers of fuels or mate- rials. While narrow boundary approaches are already accepted by some crediting registries and may be appro- priate in the near term, the carbon removal industry is still in its infancy, where taking some action is often bet- ter than taking none. As with many emerging sectors, it is common for standards to evolve over time, and these approaches may need to be revisited as carbon removal markets mature. In light of these considerations, this study provides a systems-level evaluation of the carbon removal poten- tial of CCS retrofits in the pulp and paper sector, with a focus on boundary assumptions that shape carbon removal claims. By quantifying the life cycle emissions and removal efficiencies across multiple scenarios and system boundaries, this work addresses a major gap in the literature and offers a rigorous framework for evalu- ating industrial BiCRS strategies. The findings aim to inform the design of future carbon removal protocols, investment decisions, and climate policy by highlighting the conditions under which CCS-integrated biorefineries can serve as effective and verifiable platforms for atmos- pheric carbon dioxide removal. In this study, we perform a detailed cradle-to-gate life cycle inventory of a southern U.S. virgin integrated kraft paper mill producing packaging paper (linerboard), the fastest-growing paper product [28]. The analysis includes all direct emissions associated with paper manufacturing, as well as indirect emissions from sustainably sourced wood feedstock procurement, makeup chemical produc- tion and transport, and net electricity consumption at the mill site. In addition, the associated life cycle inventory and emissions of an amine-based solvent carbon capture facility are estimated, including the embodied emissions of building the CCS facilities. Then, the net impact on GHG emissions of retrofitting the paper mill with a CCS plant is calculated, focusing on the capture of emissions from the recovery boiler. Additionally, several scenarios are evaluated to quantify carbon removal efficiency when the CCS plant is supplied with CO 2 from alternative sources. 2 Methodology The graphical abstract that summarizes the system boundaries of this study is shown in Fig. 1. This study estimates the carbon removal from integrating an

Made with FlippingBook Online newsletter maker