PAPERmaking! Vol12 Nr2 2026

Carrejo et al. Carbon Neutrality

(2026) 5:3

Page 6 of 35

CO 2 fixed by biomass − Direct & Indirect emissions associated to P & P operations − Embodied , Direct & Indirect emissions associated to CCS operation − Residual Biogenic CO 2

(1)

mtCO 2 e functionalunit

= Net Carbon Removal

CO 2 from the captured amount during pipeline transport and injection. Since standard LCA practices for coproduct alloca- tion differ slightly from the specific requirements of CDR accounting, we present two metrics to compare the flux of carbon when integrating a CCS plant into a current P&P operation. First, from the perspective of an engineered carbon removal technology, MEA solvent-based CCS, in the CDR terminology, the carbon removal efficiency is typi- cally defined as the net CO 2 tonnes removed over the gross CO 2 tonnes captured, the latter defined as what gets captured by the CCS, e.g., after capture efficiency (Eq. 5) [31]:

where the CO 2 fixed by biomass represents the theoreti- cal maximum for carbon removal and is estimated as fol- lows (Eq. 2) [31]:

CO 2 fixed by biomass = N ∗ % wtC ∗ 44 12

(2)

N represents the mass of biomass in metric tonnes used in the pulp and paper manufacturing process, and it includes the biomass used for heat and power, if any. In system 2, Eq. 1 is reduced to the biogenic CO 2 cap- tured by the CCS facility minus the embodied, direct, and indirect emissions associated to CCS operation, repre- sented in Eq. 3 to estimate the net carbon removal:

(3)

CO 2 captured − Emissions project − CO 2 losses = CO 2 removal

grossCO 2 captured − CO 2 leaked grossCO 2 captured

Carbon removal efficiency ( % ) :

∗ 100%

where:

(5)

(4)

where the CO 2 leaked refers to all the CO 2e emitted throughout the CCS operation, including indirect emis- sions from power consumption. As a second metric, we introduce the estimation of the net carbon removal efficiency, taking the ratio of the net flux of carbon removal against the total CO 2 fixed by bio- mass that can potentially be captured again (Eq. 6) [31]:

Emissions project =

E

E

E

E

capture +

injection +

embodied +

consumables

CO 2captured represents the gross amount of CO 2 cap- tured from the CCS operation. The Emissions project accounts for all of the emissions of the CCS, as shown in Eq. 4. The E capture is the sum of the emissions attributed to the consumption of electricity for the pretreatment of

CO 2 fixed by biomass − CO 2 e emissions CO 2 fixed by biomass

(6)

∗ 100%

Net Carbon removal efficiency ( % ) :

From the perspective of a CDR project capturing CO 2 from biogenic sources, existing carbon credit methodolo- gies account for CO 2 captured under the project activ- ity that would not have been captured in the absence of the project [33]. Therefore, the convention to date in the CDR industry is to take a consequential LCA approach (vs. a baseline inventory), evaluating the impact on emis- sions of the incremental CDR activities to determine net removals (Eq. 5). This sets a narrow boundary for facility retrofits with CCS, as represented in System 2. In system 3, the fossil-based (direct and indirect) CO 2 emissions from P&P operations are accounted for. As in System 2, net carbon removal is calculated using Eq. 3; however, in System 3, the definition of “CO ᔐ losses” is expanded to include onsite fossil fuel emissions from

the flue gas, CO 2 capture, compression, and dehydration, as well as the emissions associated with the consumption of natural gas and forestry residue for steam production. The E injection corresponds to the electricity used for liq- uid CO 2 transport and injection in the basin reservoir. E embodied corresponds to the emissions associated with the construction and materials of the CCS facilities for capture and transport equipment, estimated using the supply chain emission factors for commodities defined in the North American Industry Classification System [32]. The E consumables correspond to the emissions associated with the amine solvent makeup and chemicals for water treatment in the CCS and the associated transportation to the plant. Finally, the CO 2losses represent the losses of

Made with FlippingBook Online newsletter maker