PAPERmaking! Vol12 Nr2 2026

Carrejo et al. Carbon Neutrality

(2026) 5:3

Page 7 of 35

Table 2 CO 2 emissions inclusions/exclusions comparison of system boundaries defined in this analysis

Emissions accounted for in/out

System 1

System 2

System 3

System 4

System 5

Sustainable Management Forest Operations a

᪦ ᪦ ᪦ ᪦ ᪦ ᪦ ᪦ ᪦

᪦

᪦ ᪦ ᪦ ᪦ ᪦ ᪦ ᪦ ᪦ ᪦ ᪦ ᪦ ᪦ ᪦ ᪦ ᪦ ᪦ ᪦

᪦ ᪦ ᪦ ᪦ ᪦ ᪦ ᪦ ᪦ ᪦ ᪦ ᪦ ᪦ ᪦ ᪦ ᪦ ᪦ ᪦ ᪦

Biogenic CO 2 fixed by biomass P&P mill biogenic CO 2 point sources P&P mill fossil CO 2 point sources

᪦ ᪦ ᪦

P&P mill utilities

Chemicals make up and disposal a Biogenic CO 2 in paper products

᪦

Biogenic CO 2 losses Power from the grid CCS Biomass Boiler

᪦

᪦

᪦

᪦ ᪦ ᪦ ᪦ ᪦ ᪦

Wastewater treatment plant Biomass residues transportation

᪦ ᪦ ᪦ ᪦ ᪦

CCS facility utilities

CO 2 compression & storage

CO 2 losses during transportation and injection

CCS facility embodied emissions

Paper product end of life a Dynamic carbon fluxes

a Includes transportation

U.S. [34, 35]. It is important to note that the biogenic car- bon stored in the paper is assumed to be released back into the atmosphere immediately after production with- out accounting for heat or energy use. Additionally, the broader cradle-to-grave system boundary will allow the comparison of the net carbon removal in terms of three different functional units: CO 2 originating from biomass, the amount of paper produced, and biomass consumed. In most life cycle assessments, carbon emissions from biomass are classified as biogenic and are often treated as “carbon neutral.” This designation can apply to wood- derived products like pulp and paper, particularly when the wood is sourced from sustainably managed forests where harvesting does not exceed regrowth— or where carbon stocks on the landscape are stable or increasing [36]. In systems 4 and 5 of this study, the biogenic carbon entering the papermaking process is treated as the maxi- mum quantity available for atmospheric carbon removal, and net removal efficiency from CCS is evaluated relative to that amount (Eq. 6); any biogenic CO 2 released to the atmosphere under these systems is counted as an emis- sion [31]. Table 2 provides a summary view of the emissions accounted for in each system described previously: 2.1 Goal and scope This analysis assumes an already operating paper mill is retrofitted with CCS. The system boundaries defined in this study depend on the system configuration described

paper mill operations. System 3 evaluates the perfor- mance of the CCS integration under a CDR perspective, but including fossil-based emissions in the P&P mill. Consequently, the carbon removal efficiency is calculated using Eq. 5 for System 3. By applying the broadest system boundaries (Systems 4 and 5) it is possible to estimate the total impact of integrating a CCS plant into a pulp and paper facility— accounting for all relevant upstream and downstream activities—and determine whether such integration could effectively transform the mill into a net carbon sink through the capture and sequestration of biogenic CO 2 [29]. Under these broader boundaries, carbon removal is treated as inseparable from the entire pulp mill opera- tion: the removal would not occur without the harvest- ing, transportation, and processing of biomass, making the full pulping process—along with CCS— a necessary component of the carbon removal activity. The com- plete Eq. 1 is used to estimate the carbon removal in systems 4 and 5. The residual biogenic in Eq. 1 for sys- tems 4 and 5 represents the carbon content of the paper product converted into CO 2 and the biogenic CO 2 from P&P mill point sources that is not captured by the CCS facilities due to capture efficiency, or lost during trans- portation and injection. We assume all pulp products either are incinerated completely, decompose aerobically into CO 2 , or are decomposed anaerobically, such as in a landfill, where the methane is mostly flared, or oxidized, prior to emission, which is a prevalent practice in the

Made with FlippingBook Online newsletter maker