PAPERmaking! Vol12 Nr2 2026

Carrejo et al. Carbon Neutrality

(2026) 5:3

Page 8 of 35

biogenic CO 2 from the recovery boiler flue gas. Scenario 2 expands on this by including CO 2 emissions from the biomass boiler within the CCS plant, which provides the steam required for solvent regeneration in the amine sys- tem. Scenario 3 adds biogenic emissions from the P&P mill’s own biomass boiler. Scenario 4 incorporates the lime kiln, which emits primarily biogenic CO 2 , but also includes fossil-derived CO 2 from natural gas combustion used to regenerate lime. Finally, Scenario 5 integrates all CO 2 point sources from both the P&P mill and the CCS plant. As noted earlier, in Systems 4 and 5, both biogenic and fossil CO 2 emissions are explicitly accounted for— rather than assuming biogenic CO 2 is inherently carbon neutral—when evaluating net carbon removal. The functional unit in a life cycle assessment meas- ures the performance of a product system and serves as a standard unit for presenting the results (ISO 14040). However, the functional unit is intrinsically tied to the selection of system boundaries. In our study, we have selected three functional units: total carbon captured (changes with system boundary), total annual product, and total yearly biomass consumption. The last two only apply to systems 4 and 5. 2.2 Dynamic life cycle assessment Conventional carbon removal inventories treat biomass- derived CO 2 as “carbon neutral,” subtracting later emis- sions from the earlier uptake; this static view assumes sequestration happens instantly and that the CO 2 ’s interim stay in the air is irrelevant [2]. Yet the delay between emission and resequestration still warms the atmosphere, and that warming endures for a lasting period [1]. Our dynamic life cycle assessment (System 5) time stamps every emission and removal, translates these dated flows into cumulative radiative forcing, and therefore penalises lags: a tonne of biogenic CO 2 released at harvest keeps heating the climate until regrowth recaptures it (the longer the lag, the smaller the net carbon removal credit). Consequently, system 5 deliv- ers less apparent carbon removal than a static CDR bal- ance would indicate. The persistence of those emissions depends on the ecosystem carbon dynamics, which can change based on several factors such as location, climate, and ecosystem type. The temporal effect on global warming of the CO 2 emissions relies on the time the biogenic CO 2 stays in the atmosphere between when it is emitted and when it is captured again through the natural photosynthesis pro- cess. This dynamic in the carbon cycle has been studied for the immediate release of biogenic CO 2 for bioenergy production purposes [39] and different harvested wood products [40]. The absolute global warming potential (AGWP), which represents the total cumulative radiative

in the methodology section. For system 1, the system boundary is “cradle-to-gate” for the P&P operations with- out CCS, including the procurement of the wood as raw material and all the associated operations in a sustain- ably managed forest, and all the subsequent processes to transform the wood into paper during the kraft chemical pulping processes. The system boundary is shown in the top left portion of Fig. 1. The upstream associated emis- sions from producing raw materials, makeup chemicals, and fuels were included. The transportation distance of raw materials was assumed to be within a radius of 50 miles (80 km) from the paper mill. The mass and energy balances of the UBSK mill from WinGEMS v5.3 [37] Software were used as the life cycle inventory to per- form the LCA on global warming potential (GWP). Our modeled mill is 100% energy self-sufficient. Table S1 pre- sents the parameters used for the WinGEMS model. The detailed LCI data are provided in Tables S2 and S3 of the supplementary information. The GHG emission data are mainly from the Ecoinvent database, and GWP was esti- mated based on 100-year factors [38]. A modified gate-to-gate system boundary was con- sidered when independently analyzing the CCS plant in system 2. It includes all operations involved in capturing, such as the capture and compression of CO 2 from the point source (e.g., recovery boiler flue gas), its transpor- tation via pipelines, and its storage, including interme- diate storage and injection. Additionally, the boundary accounts for CO 2 emissions generated by these capture, transport, and storage activities. It also incorporates the equipment and facilities constructed explicitly for CO 2 removal and their associated emissions from materi- als and construction. Furthermore, the boundary cov- ers emissions related to the collection, processing, and transportation of biomass-derived fuel utilized by the CCS system for process heat and power and any CO 2 losses that occur within the system. In addition, system 3 accounts for the fossil-based (direct and indirect) CO 2 emissions from P&P operations, under an expanded cra- dle-to-gate system boundary compared to system 2. For systems 4 and 5, the LCA sets a broad cradle-to- grave system boundary where point sources of CO 2 emissions from the P&P mill are included alongside the CCS plant. Figure 2 represents the five point source capture scenarios analyzed. Each scenario number coin- cides with the number of point sources considered in the integration. Figure 2 provides more detail on the broad- est system boundary represented in Fig. 1, including the upstream emissions associated with P&P operations, the CCS plant, and the paper product end of life. In systems 4 and 5, the net carbon removal efficiency is assessed for each point-source capture scenario integrated into the CCS facility. Scenario 1 captures

Made with FlippingBook Online newsletter maker