PAPERmaking! Vol12 Nr2 2026

Carrejo et al. Carbon Neutrality

(2026) 5:3

Page 14 of 35

chemicals. This analysis confirms that, under current conditions, the integrated paper mill operates as a net source of GHG emissions when evaluated from a CDR perspective. Nonetheless, the relatively small fossil car- bon burden—equivalent to just 13% of the biogenic car- bon cycled—highlights how close the system is to carbon neutrality, underscoring its strong potential as a plat- form for achieving net-negative emissions through CCS integration. To assess carbon flows under alternative functional units, the standalone paper mill system (System 1) was also analyzed per tonne of paper produced and per tonne of woody biomass consumed, as shown in Fig. 6a and b, respectively. The results are consistent with find- ings from previous life cycle assessments of packaging- grade paper mills. On a per-product basis, approximately 3.9 tonnes of atmospheric CO 2 are temporarily stored as biogenic carbon in the wood fiber for each tonne of paper produced. This stored carbon is partially released during pulping and papermaking processes, while the system concurrently emits 0.5 tonnes of fossil-derived CO 2 , primarily from direct combustion and upstream energy inputs (Fig. 6a). When normalized to the amount of woody biomass input, the results indicate that 1.89 tonnes of CO 2 are stored per tonne of feedstock—based on an average carbon content of 46%—and 0.25 tonnes of fossil-derived CO 2 are emitted per tonne of biomass processed (Fig. 6b). These values provide important ref- erence points for evaluating the relative magnitude of carbon storage and emissions with respect to both prod- uct output and resource input. Together, these results underscore the significant cli- mate mitigation potential of the pulp and paper sec- tor, which processes large volumes of atmospheric CO 2 through sustainably sourced biogenic feedstocks. The rel- atively low fossil emission intensity per tonne of biomass or product positions this industry as a compelling candi- date for CCS-enabled CDR. Notably, the ratio of biogenic carbon stored to fossil CO 2 emitted—exceeding 7:1 when normalized by biomass input—demonstrates a potential for high carbon removal efficiency. Even without CCS, the system operates near carbon neutrality; with the inte- gration of capture and storage technologies, it could tran- sition into a durable, verifiable net-negative emissions platform at industrial scale. 3.2 System 2 (Narrow Gate-to-Gate): standalone CCS facility System 2 represents a standalone amine-based CCS facility assessed from a static CDR perspective, treating biogenic CO 2 as a “waste” stream. The system bound- ary excludes upstream emissions from biomass sourc- ing, onsite emissions from biomass processing, and

Table 3 Raw material, steam usage, power consumption, and CO 2 emissions of the pulp and paper mill reference scenario

Parameter

Units

Unbleached Softwood Kraft (UBSK)

Feedstock (Wood)

Logs od mt/yr

762,300 192,360 462,339 46,554

Chips

Linerboard production

mt/yr mt/yr mt/hr

NG consumption in the CHP

Steam production

329

Electrical Power Consumption

kWh/ad mt 895

Production (gross)

989

Balance

94

CO 2 Generation Recovery boiler (RB) Biomass boiler (BB)

mt/yr mt/yr mt/yr mt/yr mt/yr mt/yr mt/yr

707,748 227,379 94,106 127,926

Lime Kiln (LK)

Natural gas boiler (NGB)

Total CO 2

1,157,159

Biogenic CO 2

992,919 164,240

Fossil-fuel-derived CO 2

Wood moisture 50%, ad air dry, od oven dry, mt metric ton, kWh kilowatts per hour

systems 2 and 3—results were normalized across three functional units: total CO ᔐ removed, total annual prod- uct output, and total yearly biomass consumption. 3.1 System 1 (Baseline): baseline greenhouse gas emissions System 1 represents the standalone paper mill under cur- rent operating conditions, without carbon capture inte- gration. In this configuration, all biogenic CO 2 absorbed by biomass during forest growth is ultimately re-emitted during the pulping, papermaking, and product end-of- life stages, resulting in a closed-loop carbon cycle with no net carbon removal. However, the system also relies on fossil fuels to meet steam demand and consumes exter- nally produced chemicals such as NaOH and Na 2 SO 4 , introducing additional fossil-derived emissions into the system. Emissions from pulp and paper mill operations, including both biogenic and non-biogenic sources, are summarized in Table S7. As shown in Fig. 5, when normalized per tonne of CO 2 theoretically available for removal (i.e., the total car- bon content of the biomass feedstock), the system not only re-emits the full amount of biogenic CO 2 (–1.000 t CO 2 ), but also contributes an additional 0.129 t CO 2 of fossil-derived emissions to the atmosphere. These emis- sions are primarily associated with onsite energy use and the upstream production and transportation of makeup

Made with FlippingBook Online newsletter maker