PAPERmaking! Vol12 Nr2 2026

Carrejo et al. Carbon Neutrality

(2026) 5:3

Page 17 of 35

decomposition. This cradle-to-gate approach captures a more comprehensive picture of facility-level emissions while still maintaining a focus on process-level carbon removal performance. The maximum theoretical carbon removal remains defined as the total quantity of biogenic CO 2 physically captured in the CCS unit. As in System 2, net carbon removal is calculated using Eq. 3; however, in System 3, the definition of “CO 2 leakages” is expanded to include upstream and onsite fossil fuel emissions from paper mill operations. Indirect fossil fuel emissions in this system include those associated with forest management activities that supply wood to the paper mill, the production and transport of other raw materials and makeup chemicals, wastewater treatment, and landfill disposal. Direct fos- sil fuel emissions primarily stem from on-site natural gas combustion. Notably, the electricity-related emis- sions attributed to the CCS plant are lower than those in the standalone CCS assessment under System 2, as the energy required for flue gas pretreatment is already embedded within the energy use of the P&P operations. Additionally, surplus electricity generated by the paper mill is used to offset a portion of the CCS plant’s power demand. When only the CO 2 from the recovery boiler flue gas is captured (Fig. 8a), and both direct and indirect fossil fuel emissions from pulp and paper operations are included, the net carbon removal efficiency declines from 92% (as seen in System 2) to 55%. Despite this reduction, the project still qualifies as CDR, as a substantial amount of biogenic CO 2 is permanently sequestered. Expanding the system boundary to also capture flue gas from the CCS plant’s biomass boiler (Fig. 8b) improves the net carbon removal efficiency to 65%. Further extending capture to include the P&P biomass boiler (Fig. 8c) increases the efficiency to 72%. Detailed annual emissions for each sce- nario are provided in Table S10. Figure 9 compares the net carbon removal efficiency of System 2 (narrow gate-to-gate) with System 3 (nar- row cradle-to-gate) under a CDR framework that takes the maximum theoretical atmospheric carbon removal to be equal to the amount of biogenic CO 2 physically captured in the CCS unit. For the small boundary case, the removal efficiency remains constant (~ 92%) even as the CCS plant’s capacity increases. This is not because the system is unaffected by scale, but rather because the narrow system boundary includes only fossil carbon emissions from the CCS unit itself and excludes all emis- sions associated with the pulp and paper mill. As a result, increasing the capture of biogenic CO 2 has little effect on net efficiency within this limited accounting scope.

as well as material inputs (e.g., equipment manufactur- ing, chemical consumables), and minor CO 2 leakage dur- ing pipeline transport, the carbon removal is estimated at 585,790 metric tonnes of CO 2 annually, as calculated by Eq. 3 and shown in Table S8. This corresponds to a net carbon removal efficiency of 92%, indicating that for every 100 tonnes of CO 2 captured, 92 tonnes contribute to atmospheric carbon removal. Notably, emissions from uncaptured biogenic CO 2 and biogenic CO 2 from steam generation in the biomass boiler are excluded from this accounting perspective, since they are considered car- bon neutral. As illustrated in Fig. 7, the largest contribu- tions to residual emissions arise from electricity used in the CO 2 compression, transport, and injection stages. This highlights the importance of grid carbon intensity in determining overall CCS performance across geographic regions. To meet the steam demand of 223,000 lb/hr, a bio- mass boiler fueled by bark would generate approxi- mately 257,033 metric tonnes of CO 2 . If the CDR project expands the CCS system also to capture the biogenic CO 2 emissions from the biomass boiler, the total gross biogenic CO 2 captured would increase to 868,303 metric tonnes. The associated CO 2 emissions for this scenario are detailed in the third column of Table S8. When com- bining the flue gas from the recovery boiler and biomass boiler, the net carbon removal reaches 799,379 metric tonnes of CO 2 —corresponding to a carbon removal effi- ciency of 92%, as calculated using Eq. 5. This is the same removal efficiency observed under system boundaries that exclude biomass boiler emissions, since biogenic CO 2 is treated as carbon–neutral. Thus, CDR projects that draw narrow system boundaries—starting with point-source biogenic CO 2 treated as "waste CO 2 "— will likely yield high carbon removal efficiencies (> 90%) under the assumptions and parameters used in System 1 of this analysis. Table S9 presents the CCS plant param- eters when the different CO 2 point sources of the paper mill and the biomass boiler of the CCS are targeted to be captured. 3.3 System 3 (Narrow Cradle-to-Gate): paper mill and CCS facility System 3 represents an integrated system that includes both the pulp and paper facility and the amine-based CCS unit, assessed from a static CDR perspective. In this framework, biogenic CO 2 is treated as a “waste” stream similar to System 2. The system boundary includes onsite emissions from biomass processing at the paper mill and upstream emissions from biomass sourcing but excludes downstream emissions from paper product

Made with FlippingBook Online newsletter maker