PAPERmaking! Vol12 Nr2 2026

Carrejo et al. Carbon Neutrality

(2026) 5:3

Page 27 of 35

CO 2bio . One and two-year service life scenarios are also considered to reflect potential risks such as rough han- dling, moisture exposure, and fluctuating temperature and humidity. The associated GWP bio values and carbon flux profiles are presented in Figure S7. The GWP bio , when no temporal storage of carbon in the product is accounted for, is multiplied by the bio- genic CO 2 emissions not captured by the CCS facility and the other biogenic losses. The GWP bio , when the temporal storage of carbon in the product is accounted for, is then multiplied by the equivalent biogenic CO 2 in the pulp/paper product. In the scenario where only the recovery boiler flue gas stream is targeted to be cap- tured in the CCS facility, 103.9 kmt CO 2e emissions/yr are added due to the atmospheric decay and contribu- tion to global warming of the biogenic CO 2 . This scenario represents the case where more biogenic CO 2 is emit- ted into the atmosphere among all the cases analyzed. These added emissions decrease the total net carbon removal efficiency from 17% to 12%, meaning the CCS plant integrated into the P&P operation still acts as CDR, even under the most pessimistic scenario (Fig. 14a). Con- versely, when all the CO 2 point sources are targeted to be captured in the CCS (Fig. 14b), less biogenic CO 2 is released into the atmosphere, contributing only 66.3 kmt CO 2e emissions/yr to global warming and represent- ing about 3% in net carbon removal efficiency decrease. Table S13 presents a summary of the annual CO 2 emis- sions and net carbon removal under a dynamic LCA per- spective of a CCS integrated into the UBSK mill. To assess robustness to temporal parameter uncer- tainty, the product storage period (θ) was varied from 0 to 3 years (Table 4). This variation changes the GWP bio factor from 0.0856 to 0.0655, resulting in net carbon removal efficiency ranges of 11.3–12.1% for scenario 1 (recovery boiler) and 41.8–42.4% for scenario 5 (recov- ery boiler, CCS and P&P biomass boilers, lime kiln, and natural gas boiler). Despite this 3 to 5 percentage point variation compared to static LCA results (System 4), all scenarios maintain net-negative emissions, confirming the robustness of the conclusion that CCS integration enables atmospheric carbon removal. To explicitly address the influence of product carbon residence time on the dynamic results of the net car- bon removal efficiency, we conducted a sensitivity anal- ysis varying θ from 0 to 3 years (Table 4). This analysis extends the GWP bio framework by delaying the oxida- tion of biogenic carbon in paper products according to their assumed service lifetime. For each θ value defined in Eq. 11, the CO 2 release from product incineration was time-shifted within the dynamic carbon balance, and the corresponding GWP bio factor was recalculated fol- lowing the approach of Guest et al. [49]. This procedure

effectively represents a modest residence-time distribu- tion consistent with realistic lifetimes of paper products. The resulting decrease in GWP bio from 0.0856 to 0.0655 demonstrates that accounting for temporary product- carbon storage slightly enhances the short-term climate- mitigation benefit without altering the overall conclusion that CCS integration achieves net-negative emissions. A methodological tension arises when combining static and dynamic LCA perspectives. The dynamic framework used here values the timing of biogenic carbon fluxes through GWP bio , while the static assumption of immedi- ate product oxidation neglects short-term carbon storage in paper products. This contrast underscores the trade- off between temporal accuracy and methodological sim- plicity, indicating that the static treatment may slightly underestimate the short-term climate benefits of retained product carbon. 3.6 Sensitivity analysis A screening of currently operating U.S. pulp and paper mills was conducted to identify facilities comparable to the reference mill used in this analysis. As of 2024, 64 out of 226 active mills maintain an integrated supply chain— from biomass input to the production of virgin fiber- based paper—with an annual production capacity higher than 400,000 metric tonnes, representing approximately 33% of total domestic paper production and a majority of total biogenic CO 2 emissions [62]. Most of these mills are located in the southeastern U.S., with others situated in the Midwest (e.g., Michigan) and western states (e.g., Idaho). Of the 64 integrated mills, 30 facilities operate at a scale exceeding 400,000 metric tons per year, account- ing for 24% of total national production capacity. Nota- bly, 34% of these high-capacity mills achieve greater than 90% energy self-sufficiency, consistent with the opera- tional profile of our reference facility. Mill location also plays a critical role in determining the carbon intensity of grid electricity, which is especially relevant for CCS deployment scenarios requiring external power. Understanding how carbon removal performance responds to changes in key system parameters is critical for assessing the robustness of CCS-integrated pulp and paper operations. Two of the most influential variables affecting carbon removal outcomes are the carbon inten- sity of grid electricity and the CO 2 capture efficiency of the CCS system. These factors vary widely depending on mill location, technological design, and solvent or equip- ment performance. A sensitivity analysis was conducted to explore how changes in these parameters affect net carbon removal across two system boundaries: a narrow gate-to-gate perspective (System 2) and a comprehensive cradle-to-grave perspective (System 4), assuming that only the recovery boiler flue gas is captured.

Made with FlippingBook Online newsletter maker