Carrejo et al. Carbon Neutrality
(2026) 5:3
Page 29 of 35
Table 4 Sensitivity of product carbon residence time (θ) on dynamic GWP bio and net carbon removal efficiency Loblolly Pine Rotation (years) Paper Product Storage Time (years) GWP bio Net carbon removal efficiency (Scenario 1)
Net carbon removal efficiency (Scenario 5)
25 25 25 25
0 1 2 3
0.0856 0.0812 0.0733 0.0655
11.32% 11.49% 11.79% 12.08%
41.77% 41.92% 42.18% 42.43%
than variations in injection power for maximizing the net carbon removal of the storage process. 3.7 Limitations and perspectives Integrating carbon capture and storage into current pulp and paper operations has the potential not only to reduce facility-level CO 2 emissions and associated environmen- tal impacts, but also—when applied to biogenic emission sources—to enable durable atmospheric carbon removal. This positions the sector as a promising contributor to net-zero and even net-negative climate targets. Pulp and paper CO 2 emissions accounted for ~ 2.5% of the total GHG emissions (6.3 Gt CO 2e ) in the U.S. industrial sector for 2022, signifying an important amount of CO 2 emis- sions that can be removed every year if captured and sequestered [63]. The pulp and paper industry is a well-established sec- tor anchored by a mature and vertically integrated forestry supply chain. It ranks among the largest indus- trial users of biomass. As a result, virgin paper produc- tion generates some of the highest-volume, high-purity streams of biogenic CO 2 in the U.S. industrial landscape. If these emissions were fully captured and durably stored, they could enable up to 110 million tonnes of CO 2 to be removed from the atmosphere annually. This figure rep- resents a theoretical maximum, assuming no additional emissions occur across the supply chain or operational life cycle. Given this potential, the pulp and paper indus- try is uniquely positioned to support national and global climate mitigation goals through carbon dioxide removal. The life cycle inventory for the reference pulp and paper mill is grounded in a robust technical foundation, leveraging advanced process modeling through WinG- EMS v5.3 to represent industrial operations accurately. These results were cross-validated against the Fisher- Solve database, a widely recognized industry intelligence platform that offers detailed mill-specific data, particu- larly for U.S. facilities. However, the use of secondary data sources—such as generic emission factors from the Ecoinvent database—to estimate global warming poten- tial (GWP) introduces a degree of uncertainty. Future work could improve accuracy by developing site-specific
Figure 15 illustrates the resulting trends. In System 2 (Fig. 15a), electricity carbon intensity emerges as the primary driver of performance. When power is supplied from a zero-carbon source (e.g., biomass), variations in CCS capture efficiency have minimal impact, since uncaptured biogenic CO 2 is considered climate-neutral under the CDR accounting convention. However, as elec- tricity becomes more carbon-intensive, carbon removal efficiency declines steeply, demonstrating the vulner- ability of narrow system boundaries to energy source emissions. In contrast, System 4 (Fig. 15b) reflects a full life cycle accounting approach, where all emissions—regardless of origin—are considered. In this case, net removal effi- ciency is relatively insensitive to changes in grid carbon intensity but highly sensitive to the CO 2 capture rate. A decline in capture efficiency leads to sharp reductions in net carbon removal, as all uncaptured emissions, includ- ing biogenic CO 2 , are penalized. This highlights the importance of optimizing CCS performance in configu- rations that adopt broader accounting frameworks. Importantly, even under worst-case conditions— low capture efficiency (50%) and high electricity car- bon intensity (725–750 kg CO 2e /MWh)—net removal remains achievable, underscoring the potential of CCS- integrated pulp and paper mills to deliver meaningful climate benefits. Furthermore, minor contributors, such as emissions from feedstock procurement and fuel con- sumption in transportation, were found to have a mini- mal impact under the assumptions established in this analysis. Finally, comparing the relative impacts of CO 2 pipe- line leakage and injection power consumption (Fig- ure S8), for System 4 (capturing only biogenic carbon from the recovery boiler), when fugitive CO 2 leakage increases from ~ 0% to 5%, the net carbon removal effi- ciency decreases from 17.12% to 15.6%. In contrast, the system is highly insensitive to injection power consump- tion, which was varied by ± 50% (from 2.77 kWh/mt to a maximum of 4.16 kWh/mt CO 2 ), yet the performance curves were nearly identical. These findings suggest that maintaining pipeline integrity is a more critical factor
Made with FlippingBook Online newsletter maker