Carrejo et al. Carbon Neutrality
(2026) 5:3
Page 32 of 35
5 Nomenclature α gas radiative efficiency ad air-dry CO 2 carbon dioxide CO 2e carbon dioxide equivalent CO 2bio biomass-derived carbon dioxide CO 2 fixed by biomass theoretical maximum for carbon removal CO 2 captured gross amount of CO 2 captured by the CCS facility CO 2 losses losses of CO 2 from the captured amount during pipeline transport and injection Emissions project sum of the entire emissions related to the CCS facility E capture emissions of the CCS operation from power and heat consumption to capture the CO 2 E injection emissions from electricity used for transport and sequestering of the CO 2 E embodied emissions associated with the construction and materials of the CCS facilities E consumables emissions related to the chemicals used in the CCS operation E consumables emissions related to the chemicals used in the CCS operation GWP bio residual atmospheric impact of biomass-derived CO 2 Gt gigatonnes h hour kg kilogram kWh kilowatts per hour lb pounds mt metric tonne MWh megawatss per hour N mass of biomass in metric tonnes θ storage period parameter od oven-dry SOC soil organic carbon yr year Abbreviations AGWP Absolute global warming potential BB Biomass boiler BECCS Bioenergy with carbon capture and storage BiCRS Biomass carbon removal and storage CCS Carbon capture and storage CDR Carbon dioxide removal CEMS Continuous emissions monitoring system CHP Combined heat power DACCS Direct air capture with carbon capture and storage EOR Enhanced oil recovery GHG Greenhouse gases GWP Global warming potential LCA Life cycle assessment LK Lime kiln MRV Monitoring, reporting, and verification MEA Monoethanolamine (30 wt%) NG Natural gas RB Recovery boiler
capture system design. In parallel, it may also be benefi- cial to assess the feasibility and performance of deploying independent CCS units for each major point source, par- ticularly where spatial separation or flue gas characteris- tics make centralized capture less practical. 4 Conclusions This study evaluated the potential for atmospheric car- bon removal by integrating CCS into a virgin-fiber-based pulp and paper mill across multiple system configura- tions and life cycle perspectives. The results demonstrate that while pulp and paper mills are traditionally viewed as net emitters due to their fossil fuel use and process emis- sions, they also produce large volumes of concentrated biogenic CO 2 that—if captured and durably stored—can enable meaningful atmospheric carbon dioxide removal. Integration of CCS at the mill’s recovery boiler alone could reverse the carbon balance, turning the facility into a net sink, with total removal efficiencies from 17% to 92% (metric tonnes of CO 2 removed per metric tonne of CO 2 available for removal under selected boundary con- ditions). A central insight from this analysis is the critical role of system boundary definitions in evaluating net car- bon removal. This is particularly relevant for CDR pro- jects based on retrofitting existing biorefineries. Under a narrow gate-to-gate framework, only the CCS unit is evaluated, treating biogenic CO ᔐ emissions from the pulp and paper mill as a waste stream readily available for capture. Under broader boundaries, carbon removal is treated as inseparable from the entire pulp mill opera- tion: the removal would not occur without the harvest- ing, transportation, and processing of biomass, making the full pulping process—along with CCS—a necessary component of the carbon removal activity. These com- peting assumptions lead to widely divergent estimates of removal efficiency, even for the same technical sys- tem. As such, they raise important questions for carbon markets: What constitutes the full scope of human inter- vention necessary for carbon to be considered removed from the atmosphere? These distinctions are not merely academic. They materially affect how CDR projects are valued, credited, and compared. If narrow boundaries are used, retrofitted biorefineries may appear disproportion- ately effective compared to purpose-built carbon removal facilities that must account for full supply chain emis- sions. To support environmental integrity and transpar- ency in emerging CDR markets, crediting standards and registries should clearly articulate how system bounda- ries are defined and justified, particularly for retrofit pro- jects. With the right combination of policy incentives, infrastructure investment, and methodological rigor, the pulp and paper industry could emerge as a key contribu- tor to durable, scalable carbon dioxide removal.
Made with FlippingBook Online newsletter maker