PAPERmaking! Vol12 Nr2 2026

Carrejo et al. Carbon Neutrality

(2026) 5:3

Page 31 of 35

The dynamic LCA methodology applied in system 5, particularly through the GWP bio factor, offers a valuable framework to capture time-dependent carbon dynam- ics associated with biogenic CO 2 fluxes. By incorporat- ing temporary carbon storage in products and the timing of emissions from biomass combustion, the approach improves upon conventional static LCAs. For modeling forest regrowth, a simplified cumulative normal distri- bution was used based on a 25-year rotation for loblolly pine in the southeastern U.S. (a practical assumption that enables comparability across systems). However, future studies could further enhance accuracy by integrating site-specific biomass growth models and refined above- ground estimation functions [65, 66]. While GWP bio methodology assumes immediate revegetation and does not consider surface albedo [67] or decomposition delays [39], these simplifications are common in current prac- tice and help operationalize complex biogeochemical processes [68]. Acknowledging these limitations is essen- tial, yet the framework provides a sound starting point for quantifying the climate implications of biogenic car- bon flows in forestry-based systems [69]. This study highlights the important role that P&P operations and their associated supply chains could play in achieving net-zero targets within the industrial sector. The selection of system boundaries has a direct influence on both the estimated net carbon removal efficiency and the number of carbon credits that can be issued when CCS is integrated into P&P operations. At the same time, broader or narrower boundary definitions significantly impact the cost of carbon removal, typically expressed in USD per tonne of CO 2 removed. Future studies could expand upon the current analysis by incorporating techno-economic assessments that evaluate both the cost of carbon removal and the potential implications for car- bon credit pricing under various boundary assumptions. Broader system boundaries, which account for upstream emissions from biomass harvesting, transportation, and processing, tend to reduce the net CO 2 removal attrib- uted to each pulp mill. As a result, the cost per tonne of carbon removal increases, thereby raising the implied price of carbon credits under these more comprehen- sive accounting frameworks. Rigorous and transparent definition of system boundaries is therefore essential for producing accurate cost estimates and enabling well- informed investment and policy decisions. Practical implementation of the broad-boundary LCA analyzed in this study requires a robust MRV framework that establishes a physical and contractual chain of cus- tody. This framework must begin with sustainably man- aged forests, where biomass is tracked with verifiable

records of its type, origin, and chain of custody to qualify as a reliable source of biogenic CO 2 credits. Furthermore, records of all fuel and power consumption during bio- mass processing and transportation must be available. Once the certified biomass is processed at the pulp and paper mill, verification must begin at the point source. Here, the biogenic fraction of the flue gas must be quanti- fied, for instance, using the ASTM D6866 standard to dif- ferentiate biogenic from co-fired fossil carbon [23]. While point sources like RB or BB are typically assumed to be biogenic, any fossil fuel consumption (e.g., during start-up) must be accounted for. Process historical data should be used to determine the amount of time during which the stream should not be considered biogenic. The captured CO 2 mass should be measured at the plant exit by a continuous emissions monitoring system (CEMS), which can provide the CO 2 concentration and the volumetric flow rate. This measurement must be matched by a second set of meters at the injection well. With this, it not only provides an additional layer of measurement between the facility and the storage opera- tor, but also enables accuracy in the quantification of transport losses. Finally, validating durable removal needs adherence to leading protocols (e.g., from Puro.earth or Isomet- ric). These protocols require that the CO 2 be injected into dedicated geological storage (e.g., a Class VI well) and disqualify any end-use like Enhanced Oil Recovery (EOR). Also, it is required that the storage operator con- duct long-term MRV in the storage site, including seis- mic and pressure monitoring, to ensure permanence. From a technical and operational perspective, the com- bination of different CO 2 point sources in the paper mill presents some challenges. Typically, the recovery boiler and the lime kiln are located relatively close to each other within the paper mill, as their functions are closely related to the chemical recovery cycle. However, the biomass boiler and the multifuel boilers can be located at a consid- erable distance, requiring long-distance pipeline arrange- ments within the mill to combine flue gases, which implies higher costs and more detailed designs. Moreover, all the sources of CO 2 in the process have different con- centrations and impurities that require specific treatment before being combined into a single stream. It is necessary to evaluate the performance of the solvent individually for each CO 2 point source, anticipating the carbon capture rate and the effect on efficiency from the solvent inter- action with impurities [70]. Future work should experi- mentally test solvent stability and capture effectiveness for each specific flue gas stream in a pulp and paper mill to reduce technological risks and enable robust carbon

Made with FlippingBook Online newsletter maker