PAPERmaking! Vol12 Nr2 2026

Carrejo et al. Carbon Neutrality

(2026) 5:3

Page 10 of 35

metric only considers one growth-harvesting cycle, and (6) carbon contributions from roots and surface litter are excluded from the analysis. Figure S1 shows the dynam- ics of forest growth considered in this methodology [39]. Using the full impulse response function [41, 43] that integrates the ocean and terrestrial biosphere interaction in the carbon cycle [44], Eq. 8 is represented as (Eq. 10):

t

b ( t ) = y ( t ) − 

(8)

0 g ( t  ) y ( t − t  ) dt 

where y(t) represents the atmospheric decay of a pulse of CO 2 molecules over time, g(t’) describes the rate of bio- mass regrowth, which removes the CO 2 released initially, and y(t-t’) represents the CO 2 fraction remaining in the atmosphere. The temporal dynamics of forest carbon uptake are central to the dynamic LCA methodology. For this analy- sis, a rotation period of 25 years was assumed, repre- senting typical commercial management practices for loblolly pine plantations in the southeastern U.S [42]. This rotation period determines the timeframe over which atmospheric CO 2 removed during photosynthesis is re-sequestered following biomass combustion. The for- est regrowth dynamics are modeled using a cumulative normal distribution function that captures the temporal pattern of carbon uptake, with maximum uptake occur- ring at the midpoint of the rotation cycle. This approach, developed by Cherubini et al. [39], accounts for the radia- tive forcing impact of biogenic CO 2 during the interval between emission and resequestration through planta- tion regrowth. The dynamics of forest growth, expressed in Eq. 8 by g(t’), is shown in Eq. 9 [39]:

i = n  i = 1

i = n  i = 1

2 2  a

τ i  dt

t

1

− 

− ( t − μ)

t − t 

t τ i

−

−

a i e

b ( t ) = a 0 +

a i e

e

2 σ

0 +

√



2 πσ 2

0

(10)

where τ denotes the distribution relaxation time scale of the CO 2 emissions in the climate system within the natu- ral C cycle, which represents how quickly or slowly the CO 2 is taken up by the ocean (upper and deep), terres- trial biomasses, and rock weathering or sediment forma- tions. The μ(mean) denotes half of the rotation period in biomass growth (μ = r/2), being r the rotation period, and the σ (variance) is assumed to be equal to half of the mean (σ = μ/2) [45]. The GWP bio factor is invariant across spatial scales, from individual stands to entire landscapes [45], and the cumulative impact of a pulse emission is equivalent to the steady-state effect of continuous emissions [46–48]. While the above assumptions address the timing of pulp mill-based combustion emissions and subsequent forest regrowth, a significant portion of the harvested carbon remains temporarily sequestered in the liner- board product before eventual end-of-life disposal. To account for this temporal storage effect, the methodol- ogy developed by Guest et al. [49] was applied, which modifies the atmospheric decay function b(t) to incor- porate the time period during which carbon is stored in the product before being released as CO 2 (Eq. 11). This approach recognizes that delaying CO 2 emission (by stor- ing carbon in the product) reduces the cumulative radia- tive forcing compared to immediate release.

− ( t − μ) 2 2 σ 2

1

(9)

e

g ( t ) =

√

2 πσ 2

where: g ( t ) : is the atmospheric carbon uptake.

μ: is the mean, and it is assumed that occurs in the year of maximum C uptake and is taken half of the rotation period, μ = rotation/2. σ : is the variance and determines the width of the distribution, and it is assumed to be half of the mean, σ = μ/2. For the dynamics of forest growth and carbon cycling, the following assumptions were considered. The analysis begins with a mature loblolly pine plantation ready for harvest. Upon harvesting, (1) the biomass feedstock orig- inates from a stand in which all trees are the same age, and (2) harvesting is carried out by clear-cutting, with the site replanted immediately. The harvested biomass is then processed at the pulp mill, where (3) all of the biomass- derived carbon that is not retained in the paper product is combusted in mill operations (recovery boiler, biomass boilers, lime kiln), and the resulting CO 2 is treated as an instantaneous emission pulse. Following this emission pulse, (4) by the end of the next rotation period, planta- tion regrowth absorbs the same quantity of CO 2 that was released during combustion. Additionally, (5) the GWP bio

b ( t ) = 

θ 0 g ( t  ) y ( t − t  ) dt  , for 0 ≤ t <θ

b 1 ( t ) =−  b 2 ( t ) = y ( t − θ) −  t θ g

( t  ) y ( t − t  ) dt  , ft ≥ θ

(11)

Equation 11 introduces a storage period parameter (θ) representing the time between paper production and end-of-life incineration. For this study, θ = 3 years was assumed for linerboard packaging, representing an opti- mistic service life in storage, distribution, and moving applications. The climate impact of biogenic CO 2 pulses is estimated by multiplying the GWP bio factor by the amount of biogenic CO 2 within the system boundary. A virgin fiber integrated paper mill can be conceptu- alized as a hybrid system comprising a natural carbon uptake process—through the use of wood that removes CO 2 from the atmosphere via photosynthesis—and an

Made with FlippingBook Online newsletter maker